News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by snuxoll on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:03PM (#14763613)
I add two at a time without much problem, mind you I have a rather extreme setup with an external 12-bay enclosure but I feel most people building a NAS instead of buying an off-the-shelf system from Synology/Drobo aren't looking to cut costs or corners.

A 4TB Seagate IronWolf drive costs $129 off Amazon, buying two to add as a new mirrored vdev to my TrueNAS box isn't outrageous.

Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by problems on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:10PM (#14763687)
You're limited then to only mirroring, you can't do RAID6 or similar on a massive array where you're only giving up 2/10 drives space but can have a 2 disk failure. Seems like a lot of wasted disks when the only thing I'm dependent on the NAS for is not losing my TV collection. Right now I know if that if I go out and buy 2 more 4 TB disk I get 8 TB more in my NAS and at the price of an only slightly increased risk of having more than 2 drives fail at once. That's probably my favorite feature of RAID6 for a home NAS.

I actually went custom because those off-the-shelf boxes are either very expensive or have weak CPUs so can't be used for video transcoding very well - it's cheaper to build it yourself, much cheaper if you already have old hardware to dedicate to the task.

Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by snuxoll on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:25PM (#14763834)
Different use cases I suppose, my FreeNAS box stores my video collection and all the usual stuff but I've also got all the VM's that run my home network stored on it - performance+resliver times are a lot more important to me than storage efficiency.
Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by problems on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:48PM (#14764006)
And your network-running VMs have high disk IO requirements?
Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by snuxoll on Thursday July 13, 2017 @05:05PM (#14765225)
All of my virtual disks are hosted off my FreeNAS, I've got a direct 10GbE link between it and my oVirt host - raw throughput isn't so much the issue most of the time as IOPS are, I've got a local gitlab instance, OpenShift, some PostgreSQL databases, etc. and they like to hammer the crap out of my storage when in use.

Having an L2ARC helps out quite a bit, but only having 32GB of memory and wanting to keep most of it for the L1ARC means I still hit my spinning disks regularly (and mirrored vdev's help read IOPS tremendously in this case).

Re:ZFS Is the Best Filesystem For Now by tscs37 on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:09PM (#14763682)
Reducing the cost of a custom system isn't irrational.

My own personal budget is very limited, buying two IronWolf HDDs in this case is easily a good chunk of my monthly income. If I can build a NAS that can expand with single drives as needed, it's more cost effective for me.

And I imagine a lot of others have the same problem.

In the end, by buying 2 drives when a single drive could have solved the problem equally well: expanding your space by 4TB, is wasting money. Period.