This exactly. That's why I always pay cash, incl. tips. A charge on a credit card is essentially a loan from the Credit Card Company at the agreed upon interest rate. So I'm not comfortable taking out a loan to pay for my food -- granted you don't pay any interest if you pay your bills in full on time, but still it just feels wrong.
I also pay cash because I want the wait staff to get the entire tip amount I leave -- usually generous around 25% to 30% minimum. Because I was told by several waiters (mostly at Indian / Pakistani restaurants here in San Francisco) that if the tip is left on the card, that they never see it ever * .
[ * A waiter friend at Dosa on Fillmore told me this is illegal and that I should report it. Who do I report it to? And will they really take action? In a couple of Indian restaurants in downtown, the wait staff doesn't get the cash tip either. 1 waiter friend discouraged me from leaving any tip because they don't get a single penny. I tried to insert some cash in his pocket and he got scared. I think the owners forbid them from taking any cash from customers even if it's tip ]
This is because: a. Almost all US merchants take all VISA or MC branded cards, while in Europe many vendors will only take debit cards because of lower fees.
b. The USA doesn't have chip-and-PIN, so it's laughably easy to use a stolen bank card. At least now with EMV and signature, someone has to actually go through the trouble of stealing your card instead of just cloning it. But there are still a ton of merchants that are just using mag swipe ...
I would expect banks to soon start limiting the amount that can be charged via the mag stripe to slowly close this loophole. $100 per transaction should be sufficient for the majority of use cases.
Gas stations are currently the major holdouts due to the cost of switching out the terminals on pumps.
Europe uses chip and PIN, where you have to enter a numeric code at the time of each transaction that is used to unlock the card. So, you need PIN and card, the traditional what you have / what you know.
A lot of European banks even issue EMV readers that connect to your PC for online shopping and banking.
In case the thief really does manage to "clean out" my checking, I usually keep most of my money in savings and only transfer back when necessary. Savings could probably be cleaned out too if someone has my PIN, but if one's just using it for credit transactions, then at least most of my money's safe.
That all said, I still do take a lot of precautions with my card. Namely: I only use it at places that I trust. Everywhere else, I use cash.
If you use your debit card as a debit card, you will be asked to enter your bank PIN, which is sent back to the bank and validated with them. That's different than EMV chip-and-pin, where the PIN is actually presented to the card itself to unlock it. So, your card has a chip and you enter your PIN, but it's not "chip-and-PIN" in EMV parlance.
If you use your bank card as a credit card, then you'll be asked to sign for your purchase just like if you used a credit card.
Here's a primer: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/us-dete...
And here's a list of chip-and-PIN cards offered in the USA (not many) http://www.cardrates.com/advice/chip-and-pin-credit-cards/
https://www.cardfellow.com/emv-pin-debit/
Your linked list is of the "best", it is certainly not exhaustive. My chip and pin card, for example, is not listed (though a different one from my bank is, and I have seen no reason to believe they differ in this regard).
Too bad I can't report anonymously like you can for DHS violations.
Because the owner of the establishment is a very good friend of mine. But I feel obligated to report him as the waiters are also friends of mine and they are just being robbed blind (cos as it is they work for less than minimum wage)
> A charge on a credit card
The desire to make sure the waitstaff gets your tips still applies.
I never use debit cards, for all the reasons that @URSpider94 has stated elsewhere in this thread... Permalink => https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14755538
It's the golden rule. He who has the gold rules. [1] The one with the balance of power wins.
[1] Let's say in the normal course of business you are owed $5000 and have been trying to get a deadbeat customer to pay for a year. It's obvious that you don't want to get paid in pennies. In this case the customer says 'I will pay you but it has to be pennies'. What would anyone do? Accept the pennies.
However, you won't be able to go to that restauran again.
Also, I believe even if they WARN YOU in advance that they don't take cash, you could STILL go and eat and then offer cash! Because LEGAL TENDER. Estoppel is only a defense, can't be used to prosecute someone and get them to pay by VISA.
[1]http://www.news-leader.com/story/news/watchdog/2014/12/24/as...
"What about debts already incurred, such as a restaurant bill presented after the meal is eaten, a lawsuit judgment or an annual tax bill? For those debts, a plain reading of the Coinage Act suggests that any kind of legal tender, whether coins or bills, must be accepted."
I'm pretty sure dine-and-dashers don't just get sued - they get arrested.
I'm wary of people offering legal advice and interpretation without some credentials.
I'm getting the popcorn for that
Even better luck trying this in front of a judge
For those of us who want to fight "on the other side" of the war on cash -- ie to keep it in circulation -- such a campaign would be worthwhile. I, for one would participate. Someone should make a website with a list of the establishments that partnered with VISA on this crap and post it here :)
Seems like asking for an immediate credit card pre-auth wouldn't be that much of a shift in cultural norms.
On the fast-food and fast-casual end with payment up front, OTOH, this might work in theory, but that's the segment that can least afford to exclude the unbanked, so the payment is going to have to be significant.
What the restaurant would need to do is ask you to pay up front with visa, or to provide your visa prior to ordering so that they could charge you. That would solve the problem if they charged you before you ate the meal, but if they try to charge your visa after the meal and the charge is declined, you can still settle with cash.
But somehow, with the tax avoidance issues with tips, they would either not do this or ask for the tip in cash.
Can you really "always settle a debt with cash"? Even if you are told beforehand that the deal isn't for cash? Would this mean that I am effectively forced to accept cash for rendering goods or services?
It is, up until the point you turn it into a debt. This means you can require trading apples in return for potatoes, but you have to do the transaction up-front. So if you ran a food stand and rejected any cash transactions at the point of sale, you are completely within the law.
You could not give your apples to your neighbor in the spring, and force them to settle up via potatoes in the fall. If they wanted to, they could pay you the equivalent of their potato debt in cash.
And yes, if someone ends up owing you money and offers you cash to settle - you must accept it, with very few exceptions. All debts public and private actually does have some serious teeth after all.
A long time ago I had to settle a bet on this topic, and it was more extensive than this. The tldr; is that at no time in US history have you been forced to take US currency, with the exception of debts.
It actually does make sense. What happens in the event your neighbors potato harvest fails and they get out of the business? If you sued them in court, the court would award you the market value of the replacement cost of the potatoes you did not receive (most likely). And thus they would be settling up via cash either way.
(n) coins or banknotes that must be accepted if offered in payment of a debt.
Debt != barter
A potential workaround would be if the menu's prices were not in dollars, but instead in credit card points or some such nonsense, but even this is probably arguable.
You'd need to have your contract signed and agreed upon prior to rendering services or goods.
Once the food is ordered and consumed, you are then presented with a check. This is now a debt.
Vendors certainly are not required to accept cash during a transaction, but you are absolutely required to accept cash if someone is settling a debt.
Might be an interesting case at some point.
This is simply ignoring Visa trying to enact their merchant discount tax on every transaction within the US economy though. This road (lack of anonymous and free means of payment) ends in tears.