News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Retric on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @12:30PM (#1475358)
You often hear this but it's completely wrong.

Intelligence and Execution was not going to save Pet's.com or all those other .COM's based on stupid idea. If anything assuming Execution is what's important is a great way to separate a sucker err Investor from his money.

PS: A good idea is a necessary but not sufficient requirement for success. Shipping CO2 to Mars is not going to make you money end of story.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by rmah on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @12:53PM (#1475425)
A minor clarification: there was nothing stupid, per se, about selling pet related products online. It was their execution that was horribly flawed. Others have executed on the "sell pet stuff online" idea and succeed to one degree or another.
Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Retric on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @01:08PM (#1475462)
Why limit yourself to selling "pet stuff" online?

Edit: There are advantages and disadvantages to selling Pet stuff online. (Bad: tends to be low value per weight and vary fragmented dogs, cats, fish, birds. aka Dry fish food is reasonable to FedEx 50lb bags of dog food less so. Good: Large market and ???) Clearly you can make money selling pet stuff online but there is little reason to do that over selling kitchen supply's online.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by MicahWedemeyer on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @01:39PM (#1475544)
Be excellent at 1 thing. Trying to be all things to all people is a great recipe for failure.

If you love pets and have great connections in that community, it's a crap-ton easier to build a "pet stuff" store than a "everything under the sun" store.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by michael_dorfman on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @01:47PM (#1475579)
But that doesn't mean that there's a market for the "pet stuff" store, necessarily.

In other words: Be excellent and one thing, but make sure that one thing is worth being excellent at.

Trying to be all things to all people is a great recipe for failure, but it's not the only recipe for failure. There are lots and lots of ways to fail.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Gormo on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @02:39PM (#1475723)
I think most of the big successes that came out of the dotcom era were the ones that applied internet technologies to enhance markets that already existed.

Amazon worked; bookstores are a very viable market. Ebay worked; flea markets are common in every town. PayPal worked; everyone has a checking account.

There are also plenty of pet stores. Pets.com could have easily been a success if they had built their company properly.

What you're saying seems to validate the article's point: execute a proven "commodity" idea well, and you can succeed. Bet the company on an experimental vision, and you risk failure.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Retric on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @01:48PM (#1475585)
If you love pets and have great connections in that community

Building a pet community and then up selling stuff is an ok idea, but it's also a different idea than just creating a pet store online. Limiting yourself to just selling generic pet stuff without said community is a poor idea.

PS: If you go to pets.com now you see the second version, but they initial push was all about selling stuff and not building a community. The issue is one of trust, if you sell yourself as a store it's much harder to build a community than it is to have a community and then sell stuff (the good) stuff

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Gormo on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @02:33PM (#1475707)
Why limit yourself to shelling shoes online?
Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Retric on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @03:13PM (#1475839)
There is actually a lot to be said for selling shoes online.

Having a huge selection is extremely valuable.

It's a reasonably uniform product line with a high value to shipping cost. You can independently measure them so people can have a good idea if it will fit them etc. Unlike computer parts or toy's your inventory does not lose value quickly. And unlike jewelry it’s easy to figure out what it looks like from a picture. You are likely to be able to resell "returned" items without people noticing.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by dhimes on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @02:47PM (#1475759)
I think the comment by MS on the original site is worth a read. Basically: you need both a great idea and great execution.

Being tall won't guarantee that you'll be a great basketball player, but it's very, very difficult to be a great basketball player if you are not tall.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by theBobMcCormick on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @03:45PM (#1475944)
I'd love to read a good, impartial post-mortem of Pets.com. It's brought up in so many conversations about the .com era, but never with any concrete details.

I would assume that the big problem with pets.com was their execution. Just the amount they spent on advertising alone must have been almost impossible to recoup.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by Gormo on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @02:47PM (#1475757)
I agree that a good idea is necessary but not sufficient for success. But I think the article makes an important point in calling ideas a "commodity": what is more fungible than the same idea in two people's minds?

You can get good ideas for free. Excellence at execution is much more expensive.

Re:Ideas Are a Commodity, It's Execution Intelligence That M... by danhak on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @02:37PM (#1475715)
Yes, all things being equal, the idea itself could impose an upper limit on success.