News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by lpolovets on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:30PM (#14749500)
Not really. If a fair price for your company is $10m today or $40m in a year if you do well, there isn't a good reason to invest at $40m today (or even a discount like 20% off $40m).

An analogy: Amazon is $1k/share today. Let's say you think there's a 30% chance it will 3x in the next year. Would you like to invest at $2.5k/share today? The answer is No because that has negative expected value, and you'd rather just wait a year and invest at $3k/share than investing at a small discount to $3k/share today when the stock is worth much less than that.

Also, the time horizon doesn't change the misaligned incentives here. Because I get in at next round's price, I would prefer for that price to be lower.

Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by anotherfounder on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:03AM (#14750058)
It seems like a hidden element that we aren't talking about which really might affect everyone's reference points is the time duration between SAFE and priced rounds.

For a lot of people, I see the difference being the start of the process, and the end of process which can be a few months - in which case, an uncapped with discount seems entirely reasonable.

It seems like you are referring to a case where a substantial time has passed to materially affect the valuation in a substantive way?

Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by pcmaffey on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:07PM (#14749664)
Isn't the whole point of notes to address the uncertainty of valuation? In your example, what happens when there's no 'fair price today'? If you think there's a 30% chance Amazon will be worth 3k in a year, what price would you pay now?
Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by lpolovets on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:36AM (#14750571)
Usually fair price is based on some combination of 1) market price and 2) the investment's expected value, adjusted by some return hurdle rate. For example, if I'm looking for a 25% annual return, and next year I think Amazon is 70% likely to be $1000/share and 30% likely to be $3000/share (weighted avg = $1600/share), then a fair price might be $1280.
Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by deedorgreed on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @11:39PM (#14749994)
the point of notes is to be able to raise without expensive legal fees and be reasonable on valuation (i've done a lot of angel investing and when i invest i want a "starting point" - doesn't have to be crazy low but has to "make sense" - at least to me; 20% discount on next round isn't appealing enough {why would an angel putting money super early with the greatest chance of losing it all only get a relatively small discount})
Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by pcmaffey on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @01:03AM (#14750226)
Ease and simplicity is definitely the biggest reason notes have continued to be used. But their original purpose was to solve the problem of setting a price on early stage companies.

I agree that 20% discount by itself is not appealing enough incentive for the risk of early stage investment. But what about 40%? ...50%? A discount is just the mechanism that most accurately captures the variable nature of valuation. Finding the right number is where the modeling happens.

Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by DelaneyM on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:36PM (#14755244)
I believe 25% is the smallest discount I've seen thrown around, 40%-50% is rather common.

As was mentioned elsewhere, smaller discounts tend to apply to shorter horizons, such as when bridging immediately into a round. In those cases, they can be a good way for VCs to get on the cap table with prorata rights without having to muck around in series-A drama.

Re:SAFEs are not bad for entrepreneurs by anotherfounder on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:00AM (#14750052)
I'm unclear on how the cap would be a starting point? To DelaneyM & pcmaffey's point, it then becomes a proxy for price, so you've effectively set a valuation.

Would it be more appealing if you the round was closed in the next few months, so you investing early would be well rewarded with the discount?