News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:14PM (#14748866)
This is a pretty big misunderstanding of the situation imo. The reason the US won't directly strike NK is because of the risk to Seoul. It has nothing to do the UN (which is essentially a useless and meaningless body at this point, as Russia and China don't agree with the West on almost literally anything). Moreover, China isn't going to risk a war with the US over NK.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by vkou on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:18PM (#14748893)
The United States risked a nuclear war with the USSR over Cuba. What makes you 100% certain that China won't risk a war over North Korea?

North Korea is an important buffer state for China.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:30PM (#14748958)
The US was facing a direct nuclear threat. Risking nuclear war with the USSR was hardly an escalation. Also, there's a large difference between "risking"and "acting."

China has much more to lose than gain (economically and militarily) by warring with the US over NK.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by vkou on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:12PM (#14749168)
Serious wars between evenly-matched participants always result in said participants losing more then they gain. Somehow, though, we never learn from history.

If the US invaded North Korea, and China did nothing, it would be the equivalent of China invading Canada and Mexico, and the United States doing nothing but issuing nasty diplomatic protests. Even if it did not threaten its interests directly, the loss of face would be immense. Wars have been started over far less.

Have you forgotten how half of the US government wanted war with Russia over Crimea? A little Ukranian province, on the other side of the world? Completely insignificant to US interests?

Compared to the Crimean war, unilaterally invading North Korea is like striking a match in a gunpowder factory. I'm sure that the fools who will authorize and cheerlead it will not for one moment think that it will turn nuclear.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:19PM (#14749442)
Comparing NK to Canada and Mexico is pretty silly. Neither of them threaten China with nuclear weapons, China doesn't have the capability to project military power across the Pacific and challenge the US, and the US is very friendly with both of them. I'd also argue China is more dependent economically on the US than vice versa, though that's admittedly debatable.

While China ostensibly supports NK because it's preferable to the US, the relationship isn't nearly as close as US with other NAFTA nations. This is supported by the original article. It isn't as much of a face loss as you're supposing.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by mobilefriendly on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:55PM (#14749341)
Crimea isn't really Ukrainian, either, it is historically and ethnically Russian (and Tatar), it was an accident of Soviet history that it ended up in the country of Ukraine.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:32PM (#14749244)
China has went to war with the US over North Korea before, at a time where they didn't even have a nuclear option. Saying things won't happen due to economic and military losses is the exact rhetoric you heard before WWI and a WWII.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:25PM (#14749471)
China very nearly didn't go into the Korean war, and was betting on getting support from the Soviets when they did. Furthermore, the US wasn't under direct threat in the Korean war and was war weary from WW2. A new Korean war would likely have a more invested US, no outside help (except potentially on the US side), and a China with worse relations with NK.

In addition, the primary fear for the CCP was that the US would try to march all the way to Beijing. There's no way that would happen today, so China has much less to fear from a modern Korean War than it did in the first.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:01PM (#14749647)
You are much more confident than I that no one would help an attacked China via North Korea and that the US would never march on Beijing for a third (fourth? Not sure how many US troops were involved in the Opium Wars) time. Both things seem very possible in a world where the US invades an ally of China.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:27PM (#14748945)
Yes, China would take an invasion of a bordering ally as an act of war on them. It wouldn't be a risk of war, it would be the US declaring war on China, and much of the world's favor would go to the defender.

And yeah, the UN resolution is incredibly unlikely. That's why it would work, if China consented to the move it wouldn't trigger WWIII.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by yladiz on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:30PM (#14749235)
No it wouldn't, because China doesn't really consider NK an ally worth fighting over, especially against USA, because unlike with NK China and USA are very strong trading partners. Of course China strongly prefers a buffer between South Korea and itself, but if some action did happen, likely China would just not participate in the war and then help with the cleanup and new government since they are a border state and would require any UN resolution to have compromises. The only way China would get involved is if it involved or risked their land or people, not NK.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:41PM (#14749271)
Losing the buffer state would be seen as a direct threat on their land and people, and the UN would be powerless in a conflict between two security council members.

Strong trading ties doesn't stop war. This is one of the largest lessons of WWI, and why an isolationist leader of the US is terrifying. It's sold as putting America first, but its scarily similar to the mad dash for guaranteed access to necessary resources before WWII.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by yladiz on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:04PM (#14749369)
Are you joking? I know that China and USA do not have one, but there hasn't been a single conflict with any country that has a free trade agreement since WW2.

Also, understand that the US has the backing (and mutual defect agreements) of South Korea, Japan, and NATO, and India would possibly join in a conflict against China as well. China wouldn't want a US backed state on its doorstep, but it would not want war against the US significantly more.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:38PM (#14749552)
There hasn't been a true war between great powers since WWII, and that's more likely due to nuclear bombs than free trade agreements.

Mutual defense agreements don't matter if the US invades North Korea, the US is not the defensive party in the war. And it's easy to say that all of these sides would back the US now, an aggressive war in the region could change a lot of alliances.

Invading North Korea is not a sane option for the US unless China consents. The best case scenario sees China allowing it while preparing for a future conflict, and all out war is very possible.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:50PM (#14749065)
I'm not going to take the time to find the link, but it's been reported in the WSJ that even Obama (who is presumably more dovish than Trump) said he would order strikes on NK if it was possible to do so without risk to Seoul. It seems unlikely Obama was willing to risk war with China over NK during his term
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @08:23PM (#14749212)
That's likely true for some sort of missile strike, but a missile strike also doesn't remove the problem. Even in the event we killed Kim in a strike, the replacement would be unlikely to be western friendly.

This discussion is about "going in," which I take to mean an invasion. Any invasion attempt would start with the understanding that Seoul is going to look like London after the blitz at best.

Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by chibg10 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:31PM (#14749507)
The point of the strike would be to destroy threats to Seoul prior to an invasion (i.e. removing the obstacle). As even you noted, the US wouldn't strike and wait as that creates more problems than it solves.
Re:Why Won’t China Help with North Korea? Remember 1956 by RugnirViking on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @08:32AM (#14751925)
The threat to Seoul is mobile artillery near the border. It doesn't even have to be cruise missiles on anything like that; Seoul is close enough to the border that indiscriminate shelling at the city is probable

Mobile artillery is a very difficult problem to remove all with one strike, because it is mobile for the precise reason that its difficult to know where they all are. That's why many nuclear missiles have been deployed on trucks, so that they can be stationed in remote areas and moved at a moments notice, similarly to submarines