In short, you embarass yourself less. You already know how to make a 'good enough' simple design. You might prefer to make a glorious, exciting complex one, but odds are you don't know how. Which makes sense, because this is hard to pull off. If you stay simple, you get 'good enough'. Try to get complex and fail, you get visual torture. If you'd like to make more interesting designs, learn the techniques little by little, but make your finished products no more complex than you can be confident in.
Regarding gradients: when you do use them, be subtle. A gentle shift from one color of red to a slightly deeper one can be nice and help draw attention. A shift from red to a green will make babies cry. As a general rule of thumb, colors should only gradient towards different shades of themselves or towards black or white. Seems obvious, I know, but...
Yes. I want to share a design an unqualified team member once seriously proposed: http://img.skitch.com/20100630-m473a35wsrcwsis547mmxjetcq.pn...
Also I think it is about personal taste; my designs tend towards the same minimalist, centered, coloured menu bar, links in a certain way etc. design because I vastly prefer sites like that :)
(also the beauty of minimalism is that you can "impact" buttons and so forth really easily if you have a good colour scheme - Startup Wiki is an example of where I got this pretty wrong...... :))
For example: Holiday Inn Express just redesigned their logo to look like some Web-2.0-style icon thing with gradients and drop shadows. They look absolutely horrible on signage. They look like gas station signs now.
But as a "pretty bad designer" gradients tend to be territory that is destined to fail. :)
In the limited design work I've done, I've found it extremely helpful to look at the subject's face when they see your design. You want to see their gut reaction: you'll see displeasure in their eyes long before they'll verbalize it. You can break the social tension around criticism by saying, "Oh, I see there's something you don't like. Where are you looking right now?"
You want feedback to be a conversation - if your subject knows what you intended, they can give you hints on what you actually wanted to design.
Can they make the buttons any smaller or the scrolling any more touchy?
- bold colourful blocks
- tend towards minimalist
- use no more than 3 colours in a design
- use colourlovers.com for palettes
- copy nice bits/ideas off other people (obviously without ripping off entire designs)
- avoid gradients
EDIT: oh, one other thought. One or two fancy bits of design or JS magic == good. Too many == very bad :)
1. http://www.errant.me.uk (minamilist) 2. http://www.startupwiki.co.uk (bold colours, blocks)