News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by taneq on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @09:59AM (#14744201)
As my old boss once said, "never confuse mathematics with mere arithmetic."
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by dahart on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @11:25AM (#14744950)
I've always liked that line, but it's clearly being cheeky and there are times it's applicable and times it's not.

All arithmetic is math, but not all math is arithmetic.

Except that if you dig deep enough, all math is arithmetic under the hood. Algebra is doing the arithmetic on variables before they're numbers. Calculus is just useful shorthand for compound arithmetic; the derivative is a divide and the integral is a sum. Exponentiation is repeated multiplication, which is repeated addition. Linear algebra is arithmetic on blocks of numbers.

So we abstract over the individual arithmetic operations for our own convenience, there are too many of them. But it's all still fancy arithmetic.

Maybe we should call math "fancy arithmetic" to help all the people who are intimidated by math...

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by bjl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @12:14PM (#14745366)
Actually, the opposite is true. If you dig deep enough, it turns out that arithmetic is far more complicated than most other areas.
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by dahart on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:30PM (#14746086)
Then maybe instead of calling math fancy arithmetic, we should call arithmetic "hard math"? :P

Seems like you agree more than disagree; math and arithmetic aren't easily separable, if you're being serious instead of cheeky?

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by bjl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:42PM (#14746198)
Well, I was trying to make two points.

1) Arithmetic (number theory) is far harder than most people realise, to the point that its considered one of the most complicated mathematical disciplines.

2) Most subject areas in math bear little to no resemblance to arithmetic, so it doesn't make sense to call all math 'Fancy Arithmetic'.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by dahart on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:58PM (#14746367)
Sure, understood and I agree. I was also trying to make one point: all math is built on arithmetic operations if you dig down to first principles, so it does make some sense to call all math 'fancy arithmetic'. There is no math at all without the concept of addition sitting somewhere under it.

But I'm not actually proposing that, just sharing a cheeky point of view to contrast @taneq's boss, so don't take me too seriously. ;)

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by julian_1 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @03:48PM (#14747378)
> I was also trying to make one point: all math is built on arithmetic operations if you dig down to first principles,

I am a newb at this stuff, but I believe (basic) number theory actually builds on recursive structures, and then uses induction to make statements about behavior.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peano_axioms#Addition

What is interesting is how the same approach works for analogous structures like lists - because of the monoid abstraction.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by dahart on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @06:25PM (#14748614)
This is interesting! I'm not sure, but I think this may reinforce what I said, not contradict it. I'm suggesting that math operations we know all build on top of addition, not that addition is necessarily the atom. Addition can build on top of something else, and still sit under all higher level math.

But that said, I didn't learn addition in terms of monoids, and I don't know anyone else who did. This might be a grand unified theory of math under which addition fits, but physical addition has no recursive monoid analogue. You can add two weights together to get a measurable sum, and it does not depend on a recursive structure that uses induction. You just put two separate things side by side on the scale.

Just because we can explain addition using monoids and induction does not mean that addition is made of monoids and induction.

Also, I probably wouldn't use Peano theory as the starting place to teach addition. As a pedagogical tool, this is advanced math, and I guess would be a bigger impediment to learning than Greek symbols, for beginners. Right?

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by debbiedowner on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:07AM (#14744268)
Exactly. That's why there are three kinds of mathematicians, those who can count, and those who can't.
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by netcan on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:42AM (#14744555)
I don't understand why this point seems so important to people. Seems like a semantic point, if we're talking about math education in schools.

I mean, there is theory & practice in every field, technique and discovery. A medical scientist studying the development of aberrant cells in a petry dish has a pretty different job to a pediatrician or radiologist. They generally seem to coexist happily under the "medicine" label. For first year undergraduates, they would probably need to take most of the same classes.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by sp332 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:46AM (#14744601)
Arithmetic is theory too. Graph theory has lots of practical applications. I don't think it's that kind of divide. Arithmetic is just a very small part of mathematics.
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by jack_h on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @12:38PM (#14745609)
As someone who went to university for mathematics (and computer science) I can tell you this is the most common misconception. People think that I spent years studying how to become a calculator.

I love talking about both subjects I went to university for actually and both can be difficult to get people interested in. There are massive misconceptions about both.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by lordnacho on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:32PM (#14746098)
Yes, this is one of the most annoying things about people who don't know anything about math.

- They see a shopping bill or a phone number and ask you if you can add them.

- They see random equations, often in the background, and ask you if you understand what it means.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by taneq on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:39AM (#14750156)
It's like when you study mechanical engineering and suddenly everyone wants you to fix their car.
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by joejoebob on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:31AM (#14744450)
A professor of mine who was quite bad at arithmetic used to say, "I'm a mathematician, not an arithmetician."
Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by Koshkin on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @10:48AM (#14744615)
Yet,

- arithmetics (a.k.a. Number Theory) is a vast branch of modern pure mathematics;

- numeric calculations, i.e. how to do them efficiently, is a very important part of the (applied) mathematics.

Re:Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learni... by sanderjd on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @11:12AM (#14744827)
The parent commenter's old boss certainly did not mean Number Theory by "arithmetic".