In that case, it wouldn't double expenses. Assuming batches are slightly effective, it should reduce expenses-- with >50% success rate with batches of >=3 PRs, you don't have to do individual testing for the later PRs in the batch.
I think it would double expenses because our CI runs at capacity. To do parallel builds we would have to contract for double the compute resources. (With a different purchase structure for our CPU time you may be right about that, but not sure).
Using batch testing as a default would both reduce costs and increase merge speed, assuming that your commits usually pass testing.
The downside of using batching as a default is that it wouldn't test every commit in isolation. That means it wouldn't necessarily be safe to roll back to a particular commit if that commit was tested as part of a batch. E.g. if patches A, B and C were tested together, then it's not certain that patch A by itself would pass the tests.
For example, if the pass rate is 80%, then by batching 3 PRs together there's a 51.2% chance to pass with all three, which would save 2 test runs. and a 48.8% to fail, which would cost 1 extra run. That's a pretty substantial increase in throughput.
So far we haven't been able to stomach doing parallel integration builds because of the doubling of expenses.
As you see, our current solution is rollups, where a human batches low-risk PRs into one big PR. It works just ok, and is super high-maintenance.