News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Librarian: Get links to references and Bibtex for papers ... by detaro on Monday July 10, 2017 @03:22PM (#14738850)
Something on arXiv can have had more "peer-review" than something that made it past 3 reviewers for a normal publication if it has been discussed a lot.

Also, not everything cited has to be properly published. If you base an argument on a finding from a source, then yes, but e.g. but descriptions of approaches, ideas, ... are things that can be cite-worthy while not requiring the "fact-checking" peer review provides.

It's an interesting balance: On the one hand, it's bad if stuff that just was published as a preprint is treated as established (which seems to be partially the case in ML right now), on the other hand not referencing good material just because it "doesn't look scientific enough" also doesn't help anyone. (In some parts of computing, it seems like academia is toying with stuff industry has tried and discarded years ago, but that isn't acknowledged because it hasn't been published in a nice citation. It's fine to do work to validate that, but totally ignoring it is weird)

There are no comments on this comment yet.