Re:Life
by justinpombrio on Sunday July 09, 2017 @05:54PM
(#14731914)
> While "Both you and the Eiffel Tower are simply bunches of quarks." is a true description (according to modern physics), it's not a very useful one.
Except that in this case, the molecular details of life are useful. If you want to know why people need salt you need to know about ion channels. (This is in contrast to your Eiffel Tower example, where you don't gain much insight by looking at molecules than you knew at the material-science level.)
Re:Life
by Turing_Machine on Monday July 10, 2017 @09:42AM
(#14735784)
But ion channels (and their function) are on a much higher level than quarks. Looking at things at the quark level doesn't tell you anything about ions, or salt, or, for that matter, people. :-)
The Eiffel Tower is "simply" a bunch of puddled iron. On an even more reductionist level, it's simply a bunch of quarks, as are you.
While "Both you and the Eiffel Tower are simply bunches of quarks." is a true description (according to modern physics), it's not a very useful one. It says nothing about why the Eiffel Tower is different from other bunches of quarks, and definitely says nothing about (e.g.) what kind of reaction you might have to visiting Paris and climbing the Eiffel Tower. Would you be scared (acrophobic)? Exhilarated? Bored? The "bunch of quarks" description is of absolutely no help there.
Reductionist models have their uses, but attempting to use them to explain everything is a grievous mistake.