Re:Life
by garrybelka on Sunday July 09, 2017 @02:39PM
(#14731041)
Let's talk about something simpler first - about movies.
We know enough about chemistry of photographic film
to conclude that movies are simply fantastically complex clockwork automatons, correct?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Incorrect, movies are not automations, they are simple data sets. Movies+players combination is, yes. But this definition from the parent comment is an oversimplification. This is how the article framed it and its TL;DR:
"living systems may be defined as open systems maintained in steady-states, far-from-equilibrium, due to matter-energy flows in which informed (genetically) autocatalytic cycles extract energy, build complex internal structures, allowing growth even as they create greater entropy in their environments, and capable, over multigenerational time, of evolution."
Re:Life
by garrybelka on Sunday July 09, 2017 @03:36PM
(#14731283)
So Yojimbo and Wild strawberries are simple data sets.
Where does inspiration come into play?
Re:Life
by crimsonalucard on Sunday July 09, 2017 @03:16PM
(#14731200)
I think the difference between life and machines is in how entropy is shifted. Life goes on while, all machines degrade over time.
Agreed. A film and its corresponding image management toolchain is a fantastically complex automaton.
Having made or worked on quite a few films, I can assure you that they don't watch themselves, and that if one has done one's job correctly they just repeat the exact same behavior every time. I would be quite interested to see a movie in which one of the characters decided to do something different from the previous viewing.
Re:Life
by garrybelka on Sunday July 09, 2017 @03:45PM
(#14731321)
Pierre Menard could have made a movie.
But even leaving that aside, and assuming for a moment that replays are indistinguishable (and one can enter the same river), would you accept that a movie is reducible to a photographic film chemistry?
Oh sure. I'm disagreeing with the idea of it being an automaton qua having some ability to adjust to interaction rather than being static like a book.