So cash in my pocket, option 1 was the "best". I had no initial outlay, the car dealer loaned me the money for free.
So yes that is even 1 more reason why option 1 worked out best for MY case. But who knows when I next get a car what will be true.
I negotiated a cash rate. I had the cash in my hand, and I got the lowest possible cash price, after talking to 6 dealers. Once I had the price printed on paper including all fees, I then said sure I will do the 0% APR loan. My price did not go up a single dollar.
Options 3 and 4 I could take that cash I would have spent on the car, and put into the stock market. It would have generated me 5-6% return, on average, over the life of my car.
The cash flow calculations vs the cash on hand - risk costs are where the math happens but it is perfectly possible to walk away with the decision to buy new to work out better on certain models of car.
Small Japanese SUVs had a very very high value retention for the first 4-5 years.
Something like maybe the sticker price new is 25k, but what you really pay is closer to 21k new. A 3 year old would be going for 17-18k. After the maths above, it ended up costing more per year to buy used.
I have friends that said the same thing about certain diesel sedans (pre mpg scandal) but never calculated it myself.
edit: my mistake, I guess you want to have 3.333 cars in 10 years for Option 4. Carry on...
not sure what 3.333 cars means
I kept the end point constant at 10 years. So it was:
* Option 1: Buy a new car, keep 10, and sell
* Option 2: Buy a 3 year old car, keep 7, and sell
* Option 3: Buy a 5 year old car, keep 5, and sell
* Option 4: Buy a 7 year old car, keep 3, and sell
At the time I was shopping, the car I wanted had really high resale. So option 1 was coming out CHEAPER per year than option 2. (new price / 10 compared to used_price / 7). Options 3 and 4 were cheaper, but not by a ton. But then the thing I thought about was:
* With option 1, the car I am driving is an average of 5 years old
* with option 3, the car I am driving is an average of 7.5 years old
* With option 4, the car I am driving is an average of 8.5 years old
So that pushed me to go for option 1. No regrets so far, my car just passed his 7th birthday. Not 100% sure I will sell at 10, but a strong possibility.
I think the simple math of "new car = always bad unless you are rich" is wrong. "new car every 3 years trading in = always bad", sure. But throw in dealer incentives and financing, and the new vs used debate can be less black and white.