News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s big battery in South Australia may prove the viab... by taneq on Saturday July 08, 2017 @10:15AM (#14725479)
I'm excited about flow batteries too, but they still have their analogues of the above.

1) Are prices publicly available yet? I haven't found one online, would be keen to know how much their 10kWh unit costs.

2) The cell has a finite lifespan which is analogous to cell degradation - the warranty covers up to 36,500kWh of delivered energy for the 10kWh model, which equates to 3650 full discharge cycles. This is more than lithium batteries, don't get me wrong, but they're not immortal.

3) I don't believe lithium batteries need constant cooling in most cases, especially since for bulk storage your discharge rate is going to be less than 1C.

4) Fair call, lithium batteries have some scary failure modes.

Also, the round trip efficiency of these batteries is only ~77% which is a fair bit lower than lithium (I think they're 90%+?) and represents a large loss of energy over the life of the battery.

Overall I agree that there are significant advantages to flow batteries, especially at grid scale, but they do have drawbacks too.

There are no comments on this comment yet.