News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by IshKebab on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:09PM (#14721648)
This is really confusing. I just bought a house in the UK, and the process is as follows:

1. Look for house on Rightmove or Zoopla. 2. Call the estate agent or private seller to arrange a viewing. 3. Show up at the appropriate time. Look at house. 4. Make an offer. Offer gets accepted/rejected/they want more. Repeat until you get it or get outbid or give up. 5. Offer agreed (hopefully). Now do all the actual buying through mortgage brokers and solicitors.

The estate agents charge the sellers a percentage, which is cheeky because they do almost nothing - the only reason you should ever use one is if you are incapable of taking photos or really can't spare a few evenings to show people around the house.

But nobody ever drives you to see houses or finds them for you. How does it work in America?

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by svachalek on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:01PM (#14722064)
In the US, the real estate industry controls the MLS "multiple listing service" which essentially makes them the Google of houses, with negligible competition coming from classified ads, Craigslist, and the like. They charge a standardized 6% commission to the seller, which they split with the buyer's agent, and both agents end up giving some to the brokers that handle the actual transaction.

In recent years, they've been losing ground on the commission so often it's less than 6%, and the buyer may end up getting some share of his/her agent's cut as well, but so far it's pretty hard in most markets to work around the cartel.

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by lukevdp on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:48PM (#14721946)
USA has a different system than in the U.K. Or Australia.

In the US, buyers go and get a buyers agent to help them buy the house. Buyers agents get 3% and sellers agents get 3%. (Actual amounts varies wildly)

In UK and Australia, 99% of people do not use buyers agents. The agent showing buyers through the house and answering all the questions works for the seller. There is only one agent so only one commission.

Selling privately is popular in the U.K., but much less popular in Australia however the segment is growing). USA less so again.

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by AJRF on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:08PM (#14722118)
Rightmove is a property portal, Redfin is an online residential estate agency.
Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by ryuker16 on Saturday July 08, 2017 @12:01PM (#14725845)
Older people are hesitant because traditionally before the internet, for sale by owner homes had a bad reputation(iffy homes sold by cheap asses with hidden issues) and the real estate agent was the best choice for most.

I was helping my parents sell they're home and get rid of those con-artist real estate agent....they acted as though I suggested crazy talk for months on end to do for sale by owner.

Lastly some seller agents will refuse to visit or show for sale by owner as a professional courtesy issue(protectionism).

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by existencebox on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:41PM (#14721887)
I can only speak of hot markets in America, which are VERY different than many others, but at least within that:

A "reasonable" house goes on the market. ("reasonable" defined by <1 mil, within an hour commute of a city center) This house will usually be sold within a week or two. Usually less. Definitely less, if it's actually priced within middle-class-affordability (and I laughably define that as ~400-500k). I've seen houses sell the day they listed. The selling process involves showing up at the house during an open house (viewings are possible but rarer in hot markets as typically it's a race to get your offer in and sellers know they don't need to be accommodating; even viewing my house during the closing process was a "if we can fit it in" sort of thing from the seller side) You don't really get to "repeat". If you're very lucky they MAY tell you a competing bid went over your escalation threshold, but for 80% of the houses I put offers on, they look at the escalation guidelines and offers and just make a choice right there. Typically at least someone has offered +50/100k in cash and is going without a loan, so they'll often nab the house without a back and forth with any of the other offers. If the seller agrees, the closing begins. The buyer usually gets 1 shot to make an impression for a given house, usually having to put the offer together within 12 hours/a couple of days max, having seen the house once, usually with a bunch of other people.

A real estate agent helped me in multiple steps of the above.

- Having an offer ready ahead of time with lots of contingencies/tradeoffs well understood so we could tune it quickly and get it out and under the wire.

- Knowing how and where to look for houses before listing, IMMEDIATELY after listing, and that may have been listed ages ago/at bad prices.

- Able to get us contacts with the sellers if an open house time won't work/if we need to ask questions.

- When our BOA agent left us high and dry, he hooked us up with a trusted local lender with a good reputation and used his prior working relationship with her to get our file pushed through in a ridiculous timeline over a weekend so that we could put in a competing bid. (as I said, timelines are nutso)

- Gave us advice on what parts of our offer would have what impact, to what sellers. e.g. 5k vs 3k vs 10k escalation steps? What other caveats? Should compromise on preinspection? etc.

- If anything went wrong, if we had followup questions, needed contacts, he would be extremely accessible, would give us contiguous care (and thus knew what our preferences were, what we were looking for, what offers we were comfortable with/what our finances were) which saved time in rehashing that every few weeks with a new agent; and given that you WILL lose most of the offers you make, this process can go on a very long time so continuity is nice. (we were on the market 1-2 years)

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by balls187 on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:55PM (#14722004)
Did you look at areas that haven't been gentrified?

Plenty within 1 hour of Seattle that are affordable.

Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by existencebox on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:00PM (#14722047)
That's more or less where I ended up buying, and managed ~400 for a respectable 3b2b. That being said, the gentrification is spreading so aggressively and was already well in place even when I bought; in the last month 3 of my neighbors went on sale, all sold within a week at far higher prices than comparable for when I bought. (I only had... 2 other bidders, if I recall, when I bought, so it's certainly less hot than redmond where 10-15 competing was common)
Re:Real estate site Redfin files for IPO by branchless on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:18PM (#14721706)
In Canada realtors actually do something, they look for houses for you after you tell them what you want, they attend the viewing with you, get feedback, understand what you are after.

Is that worth 5% - no. Could they be removed by tech: probably. But they are far better than the low-life estate agents in the UK who are I think the least trusted profession, perhaps now undercut by bankers.