Re:Idiomatic Redux: Implementation and Intent
by Lazare on Friday July 07, 2017 @11:05AM
(#14718867)
> they're both very different
Yes, but they exist to solve very similar problems.
> when I look at mobx I get reminded of managing crazy state trees in ember and why I went to react/redux in the first place.
You may find it feels differently in practice. Because when I look at redux, I get reminded of managing crazy state trees in redux, and why I went to react/mobx in first place. :)
To be sure, Redux has strengths too, and there are tradeoffs. But I don't think that a brief "mobx looks like ember!" really conveys much, and I think the number of people who have been happy after switching from redux to mobx further undercuts such easy dismissals.
Yes, but they exist to solve very similar problems.
> when I look at mobx I get reminded of managing crazy state trees in ember and why I went to react/redux in the first place.
You may find it feels differently in practice. Because when I look at redux, I get reminded of managing crazy state trees in redux, and why I went to react/mobx in first place. :)
To be sure, Redux has strengths too, and there are tradeoffs. But I don't think that a brief "mobx looks like ember!" really conveys much, and I think the number of people who have been happy after switching from redux to mobx further undercuts such easy dismissals.