Ask YC: How do you defend the downmodded?
I'm confused about how to defend unfairly or inexplicably downmodded comments (which I feel like I'm seeing more of lately).
My instinct is to vote them up, but I'm not sure the system properly calculates what I'm trying to say.
Because votes are permanent they seem equivalent to absolute statements. What I'm trying to do is make a relative statement (i.e, "This comment is better than its current score indicates.").
I would just vote up, but often I don't even agree with the comment. But it's polite and reasonable, so I don't see why it should be punished.
Also, I remember PG talking about weighting accounts based on whether they vote up good or bad material. And if I vote up mediocre comments all the time I wonder if I'll be punished in that system.
What does everyone else do?
(
23 comments
| 14 points
| on HN
)
I'll mod something up if it's on-topic, well thought-out, and I agree with it. I'll only mod something down if it's blatantly off topic and rude/trollish. If I simply don't agree with what they said, but they said it in useful way, I'll just leave it be.
I'm all about modding the people who post goatse links down into negative oblivion, but I think it kind of stifles discussion if you downmod simply because you don't happen to agree. Instead of dog-piling someone for a dissenting opinion, take the extra 30 seconds to write a response. It'll enrich the discussion.
And I'll add that I upmod comments that are below -1 if they aren't trollish. If that marginalizes me somehow, who cares. I'd rather people not get their karma destroyed just because they have a minority opinion. Go destroy trolls instead.
Downmodding to express disagreement will result in unhealthy group-think.
If clicking the down arrow without replying becomes a trend, then no one will want to disagree. Then where will we be?
The idea is for the community to collaboratively filter the submissions and comments so the content that is worth reading bubbles to the top, and the trash goes down to the bottom. That's it.
But these days I'm trying to spend more upmodding really good, pertinent submissions rather than comments. I want to see HN quickly return to being the resource I came to use so much for hacking, well, news. I'm finding the return on (time) invested here has fallen recently, and I want it back!
Also, FWIW, I don't generally bother to down-mod anything that is already negative. There isn't much point to it, unless you feel the poster is clearly trolling (IMO).
I tried it a few times and it seems to work. Just don't do it unless you really think it is an unfair downmodding, since it doesn't add much to the conversation.
agreement/quality*insight-number of replies
if its above 2 then i upmod.... lol