News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by lawless123 on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:18AM (#14709274)
A basic income will be necessary for capitalism to survive full automation of our society. It's really the only way the rich will be able to stay rich.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:59AM (#14709435)
> It's really the only way the rich will be able to stay rich.

Why? If the means of production and warfare run without labour, what do you need population for? Ignore ethics for a second. The rich can be plenty rich buying and selling to and from each other, exclusively, if their guns and butter churn out without workers.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by lawless123 on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:07AM (#14709475)
In that case the world will eventually consist of a single person a basement dweller in his cave playing games on planet populated by robots just to serve him/her.

Once the rich dispose of the surplus to requirements workers they would turn on each other.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by stupidcar on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:43AM (#14709374)
I don't believe social conservatives will ever accept genuine universal income, even in the face of major economic disruption caused by automation. Firstly, because it is too contrary to their instinctive ideas of fairness, secondly because it is too tempting to use it as method of social control, and thirdly because there will always be a minority that misspend their assured income, which will require an additional welfare system to help them out.

I think it's more likely we'll see a large expansion of existing welfare and food-stamp systems into a system of universal basic rationing. Probably they'll be some kind of parallel, digital pseudo-currency, in the form of spendable credits. They'll be limited to certain categories of goods, and luxury brands and most entertainment products will be banned.

I think you'll also see a requirement to do some form of "work", even artificial and meaningless tasks, in order to qualify. This is already how the system works in the UK, for example. In order to access the UK's welfare system, you are basically required to seek work, any work, no matter how menial or pointless. There is a "workfare" system whereby you work, unpaid, for commercial companies, doing things like stacking shelves for low-quality retailers, in order to get access to your welfare payments.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by mattmanser on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:00AM (#14709438)
And there's a backlash forming about this:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5168192/

I signed on once as I was between contracts and it seemed like it'd be stupid not to.

Soul destroying and utterly ridiculous bureaucracy that's feels like it's meant to humiliate you rather than get you a job.

And that was like 8 years ago, it's got worse.

Ultimately, as automation drives more people out of work, the voting base for a radical change for wealth distribution will grow and the social conservative base will shrink.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by DoofusOfDeath on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:00AM (#14709442)
I'm socially conservative, and I agree with parts of your statement, at least regarding myself.

"Fairness" will be a sticking point. It's not reasonable that some people should have to work, so that others may voluntarily sit idle.

But my other reasons for opposing universal income are different than what you listed:

(1) I suspect universal income makes inaccurate assumptions about human nature. I think that without a need to work, a large fraction of people will choose not to. I doubt universal income could sustain that.

(2) Our population keeps on growing, but our planet stays the same size. Unless this changes, we'll see increasing competition for food and living space. The fraction of the economy spent on UBI would continue to increase due to inflation of those costs.

If I turn out to be mistaken about (1) and (2), then I'd be more open to UBI.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by majewsky on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:42AM (#14709603)
> It's not reasonable that some people should have to work, so that others may voluntarily sit idle.

But it is, under the right circumstances.

If you have a mostly automated society, where only 1% of today's human work is required to design, build and service the robots that do the actual work. Now you could have each person working half an hour per week, but that would mean that you would have to pay to educate every person out there in robot design, construction or maintenance. In this scenario, it's wildly more efficient to just educate 1% of the potential workforce and have them work 40 hours per week (or maybe 2% at 20 hours). You get the same work done, but spend way less on education (and also on auxiliary costs like payroll and shift planning).

Note that I'm explicitly only arguing with economic concerns, not social ones. If you define "reasonable" in social rather than economic terms, my argument need not apply.

> I think that without a need to work, a large fraction of people will choose not to.

Why is it then, that most people who are rich enough to sustain themselves indefinitely without having to work, still choose to work?

> The fraction of the economy spent on UBI would continue to increase due to inflation of those costs.

That's a problem, but UBI doesn't change it AFAICS. You can just reword this as "The fraction of the economy spent on food and living space would continue to increase due to inflation of these costs", and it would hold true regardless of whether there's UBI or not.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by michaelt on Thursday July 06, 2017 @08:14AM (#14709758)
If 99% of people are unemployed, it's not like there will be social sanctions, shame or other negative repercussions for being part of the 99%. Ideas like "the protestant work ethic" and "the nobility of work" will all be consigned to the past, right?

What would motivate the 1% to work 40 hours a week when they could spend their time on things they enjoy instead?

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by majewsky on Thursday July 06, 2017 @10:37AM (#14710715)
An expensive hobby?
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by boomboomsubban on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:55AM (#14709655)
> It's not reasonable that some people should have to work, so that others may voluntarily sit idle

When has this not been true? The only thing that changes are the amount of people that can be idle and that the people able to get education will be more pressed to work.

>I suspect universal income makes inaccurate assumptions about human nature. I think that without a need to work, a large fraction of people will choose not to. I doubt universal income could sustain that.

What percentage of the labor force do you think are motivated purely by survival now? It's basically the unskilled laborers, anyone else has other motivations.

>Our population keeps on growing, but our planet stays the same size. Unless this changes, we'll see increasing competition for food and living space. The fraction of the economy spent on UBI would continue to increase due to inflation of those costs

Drove through 500 miles of basically nothing today. We're fine on living space for quite some time, and a combination of better food production and waste limiting would handle food availability for quite some time.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by majewsky on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:35AM (#14709575)
> there will always be a minority that misspend their assured income, which will require an additional welfare system to help them out

Does it? I mean, I cannot imagine any desirable way in which welfare could be administered that cannot be misspent. If you give starving people money, they can technically buy something other than food. If you give them food stamps or actual food instead, they can trade that for money to spend on useless junk.

The only alternatives are to admit them to closed therapy, if the cause of their misspending is an addiction or other mental illness, or to force-feed them, which I would not want because it defies my concept of human dignity.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by ekianjo on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:17AM (#14709512)
Full automation is way farther than what people think. Already in early 20th century peoPle were dreaming of robots to do all menial tasks yet one century later still not even close to that.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by TausAmmer on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:34AM (#14709344)
Automation can take care of owners, food, clothing, resources, education. You preserve some exceptional people that improve automation. Why do you need other people around?
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by mr_luc on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:19AM (#14709516)
I think the argument is that you 'need other people' because those people can vote. The theory is that this ensures that automation is socially benevolent.

The theory is that increasing leverage continues to produce even more super-concentrated wealth, creating both the means and the political will (in the form of enlightened self-interest of the ultra-rich) to use surplus wealth to do things like Basic Income.

It's plausible, I guess. But I don't think that timeline is necessarily a lock.

'Other people' can vote in a democracy, but that may not be enough!

The mass of people used to have more convincing political/market power, due to the world needing them as 'wet robots' for labor. In the absence of real power for the mass of people, in the absence of the world actually 'needing' them for their output, I'm skeptical that mere democratic institutions are a good enough protection.

Democratic institutions, despite their relative benevolence, have historically have extended political power to people who are already de facto powerful (at least powerful enough to demand a seat at the table!), whether it be wealthy property owners in the age of the 'one-class' society, or the working heads-of-household during the heyday of human labor.

Power finds a way in any human system, is all I'm saying, and to the extent that increasing numbers of people lack power in the market, I'm skeptical that democratic institutions will guarantee benevolent social outcomes.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by lawless123 on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:44AM (#14709378)
>Why do you need other people around?

They might wonder the same about the owners. The French Revolution didn't work out well for the owners.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by maeln on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:01AM (#14709446)
It actually did work out great for owners. The French Revolution was not the perfect "people" revolution that a lot of people think it is. The people who mostly gain from it were the bourgeois who were really restrained under the royality. That's why one of the first right of the Declaration of Human Right is the right to possess.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by majewsky on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:49AM (#14709626)
> That's why one of the first right of the Declaration of Human Right is the right to possess.

Wherein by "first", you mean "17th article" (or 30).

https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Huma...

EDIT: Ah, I forgot about the context of the French Revolution, so I looked at the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_the_Rights_of_M... of August 1789. The right to property is actually the last article in that one, so the original point remains debunked.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:55AM (#14709411)
You can see this in action today with "the resource curse". If you can get mega rich by digging stuff out of the ground then you only need enough modern society to support that activity. If you can get foreign engineers then you can let your country rot while you fly around in your personal jumbo jet.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by Anderkent on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:45AM (#14709380)
In a purely selfish model, because when people are made completely redundant, they riot. And because (fortunately) the automate-everything folk are not who makes the laws.

In a actual human model, because the point of technology is to make human lives better, and not just to get more technology.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:33AM (#14709336)
> It's really the only way the rich will be able to stay rich.

This seems to be a great pitch for convincing rich people to help introduce basic income. Basic income is in their best self-interest. If no one has money to buy their stuff, they’ll stop being rich!

Re:Mark Zuckerberg again defends government giving people fr... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:49AM (#14709394)
I believe this is the original pitch that Bismarck used to introduce the modern welfare state, though it was more about not having your family dragged into the street and shot by revolutionaries who didn't believe your claim to be the God given ruler of the country.