News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by pjc50 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:00AM (#14700875)
Is it? Is there any evidence that it's converting the signals to symbols and performing arithemtic on the symbols? Or is the signal processing being performed "directly", through the essentially analogue operation of the neurons?

Otherwise you're asserting "doing arithmetic" as a property of any analogue system, and would say that a falling ball needs to understand calculus in order to make an arc.

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by hasenj on Thursday July 06, 2017 @07:14AM (#14709503)
I see what you're saying, but I think the comparison to a falling ball is not fair.

The brain is doing purposeful data processing. Yes it's just signals doing their thing following the laws of physics but that's also what computers do.

Arithmetics in a CPU are just electrical signals passing through wires. If you were to look at these signals without any awareness of why they are flowing this way here and there, you wouldn't be able to tell that these signals are an encoding of some arithmetic operations.

If processing audio and visual signals does not involve doing arithmetics, then what does it involve?

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by kazinator on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:20AM (#14701208)
An operational amplifier performs arithmetic.
Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by pjc50 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:41AM (#14701312)
Not symbolic arithmetic though, and the answer is not precise.

If people are going to argue that inanimate objects perform arithmetic, they will need to define arithmetic. Digital or analog calculators do it symbolically, subject to interpretation of the symbols by a human.

If a human is using a calculator or an abacus or blackboard to perform arithmetic, would we also say that the abacus or blackboard performs arithmetic? (Great, now we have to define "performs")

Re:The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else by mannykannot on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:31AM (#14702218)
Why stop there? by the same sort of argument, one could say that it not only computes arithmetic, but it is a quantum computer.

The way I see it, an operational amplifier, or a person catching a ball (to take an example from another post here) is performing a task that can be analyzed mathematically and modeled arithmetically, which is not the same as doing the analysis or setting up the model and performing the calculations.