News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bee Sting Theory of Poverty by btilly on Monday June 28, 2010 @04:15PM (#1469298)
Your argument misses the fact that there is a huge difference between not having money and being impoverished.

Sure, adding one more impossible task on top of everything else a person who views the world as a set of impossible challenges does not significantly change that person's miserable life. (Your odds of collecting are admittedly low though.)

However there are plenty of other people with similar incomes who manage to make ends meet. For those people, adding the additional burden can easily make all the difference between holding everything together and having their lives fall apart. That's a huge change in utility. (I can name two of these off of the top of my head.)

Furthermore there are other people who are temporarily impoverished. They weren't so. Now they are so. They may be better soon. Punitive measures like the ones you suggest can greatly lessen their odds of coming out of poverty. (I can easily name multiple friends of mine who were temporarily homeless with no resources, who managed to reconstruct their lives.)

There are two excellent reasons why the bee sting theory of poverty can be correct, which would invalidate your conclusion that it is not bad to heavily tax the poor.

There are no comments on this comment yet.