Re:Bee Sting Theory of Poverty
by yummyfajitas on Monday June 28, 2010 @03:40PM
(#1469169)
If U(4 bee stings) > U(5 bee stings), a poor person would attempt to eliminate a bee sting since they would increase utility by doing so. The fact that there is a spike at x=0 bee stings is irrelevant, it does not make it pointless to go from 5 stings to 4, it just means that going from 1 to 0 makes you happier than going from 5 to 4.
If Karelis asserts there is no utility gain in going from 5 to 4 bee stings, then Gain = 0 = U(4 bee stings) - U(5 bee stings), or U(4 bee stings) = U(5 bee stings). That's a flat utility function.
Would it make any sense at all for you to attend 1/2 of medical school if you wouldn't eventually enjoy the pay-off of becoming a doctor? Would doing half the monumental amount of work to start a successful business make you rich? And yet you probably wouldn't think that you have a flat utility function, would you?
You've just described exactly what a flat utility function means. U(0 years of med school) = U(half of med school). And similarly, there would be no harm in kicking people out of med school who would not finish anyway.
There's no point in <i>curing</i> anything less than all the bee stings, because of the huge drop-off in their utility function. Would it make any sense at all for you to attend 1/2 of medical school if you wouldn't eventually enjoy the pay-off of becoming a doctor? Would doing half the monumental amount of work to start a successful business make you rich? And yet you probably wouldn't think that you have a flat utility function, would you?
2.) This is only relevant if you make the flat-utility function assumption, which I don't think is true.