News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by TheOtherHobbes on Monday July 03, 2017 @12:28PM (#14689478)
It doesn't account for the unknowns in our knowledge. All it does is replace best guess single value estimates with probability distributions - which is a useful exercise, but is still statistical hand-waving.

The last four terms in the Drake equation are completely unknown. There's no point even trying to estimate them, because we simply have no clue how to estimate realistic distributions. We don't even have good data yet on the frequency of earth-like planets throughout the galaxy, because our planet-hunting techniques aren't sensitive enough to provide useful accuracy. We have some idea how many rocky planets exist in habitable zones, but there's no way to get from there to an accurate estimate of truly habitable planets.

The third term is only slightly more amenable to estimation. What does "life" mean? Clearly for Drake it means life that can send signals we might pick up after a scientific search.

But it life sends something so completely unexpected that we're not only not looking for it, but likely to overlook it, then we won't see it - for many possible reasons.

What's the distribution? No one knows.

So in fact, there are no useful priors for most of the equation.

As the over-used phrase says, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It's evidence of absence of evidence, and it's unwise to be too dogmatic about drawing further conclusions.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by ghaff on Monday July 03, 2017 @12:59PM (#14689728)
The Drake equation ends up mixing some terms we think we know fairly well and are either large or suggest something is not that uncommon with terms that are, as you say, completely unknown.

Then throw in that, based on human experiences and intuition, one in a trillion or whatever is an incredibly rare event. But that isn't a fair estimation for an event that may be truly rare.