I mean, it is called a paradox, so it implies an expectation of a different reality.
Yes, but the expectation is "if this model is right, there should lots of aliens". It's not trying to convince you the model is right, but raising the question of what is wrong given that the model appears to be contradicted by observation.
It raises a question, that is basically "how do we need to adjust this model to explain the fact that we've not yet met anyone?"