News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by taurath on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:24PM (#14680234)
If you have a job where you are working 12 hour days and weekends, your job is your life. I am actually curious when would an actual appropriate time to ask someone on a date might be - clearly the second someone brings up professional stuff, it should be out the door, but the veil of that can be breached with a simple "what have you been working on lately"
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by criddell on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:45PM (#14680320)
> when would an actual appropriate time to ask someone on a date might be

If you are in a position of power over another person, I would say there isn't an appropriate time. The number of hours you work isn't really relevant.

Put it this way: when is an appropriate time for a college professor (that works long hours!) to ask a student out on a date?

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by tanderson92 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:50PM (#14680337)
> when is an appropriate time for a college professor (that works long hours!) to ask a student out on a date?

A student generally or one of his students? There is a difference. And not too long ago a professor dating a student that he/she didn't have power over was not that uncommon.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by JadeNB on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:55PM (#14680363)
> And not too long ago a professor dating a student that he/she didn't have power over was not that uncommon.

There are a lot of things that are not uncommon, but are still totally inappropriate.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by JadeNB on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:07AM (#14681804)
> > And not too long ago a professor dating a student that he/she didn't have power over was not that uncommon.

> There are a lot of things that are not uncommon, but are still totally inappropriate.

Sorry! I was responding late at night, and, even though I quoted it, I totally missed tanderson92 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14680337) 's caveat "that he/she didn't have power over", which, of course, totally changes the ethics.

(It still doesn't seem persuasive to me to argue the ethics of a behaviour in terms of what used to be common, since it is still true that a lot of awful things used to be, and still are, common; but my comment was mostly based on a misinterpretation.)

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by resf on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:06PM (#14680419)
What's inappropriate is for a third party to decide when and when not two adults can have a private relationship.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by noobermin on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:43PM (#14680774)
Wait a second, if there is no power inbalance, how is it inappropriate? Are we merely arguing about social mores without any reason?
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by theWatcher37 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:58PM (#14680379)
You don't have an answer because you're not applying hard logic and rules but slippery moral constructs that revolve around the right people/outlets signaling that you need to be outraged.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with asking someone on a date. If they say no? Cool. Yes? Awesome. The act itself is not criminal, actions taken based on that (like retaliation) are.

Demonizing basic human behavior has no place in western society.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by watwut on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:51PM (#14680792)
"If you are in a position of power over another person, I would say there isn't an appropriate time."

Is neither illogical nor slippery moral construct. If you disagree with the rule, you should find better argument then just calling it "not hard logic enough".

On related note, if hiring manager asks for dates regularly, any hired women will be assumed less competent and assumed to sleep her way to success - no matter what her response. It is not like these accusations were far away for good looking women, they are pretty much guaranteed in this setup.

That is not cool.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by throwaway05285 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#14680956)
If you make more money than another person or can possibly benefit them in some way or the person is attracted to you then you are in a position of power. You're argument is absurd and out of touch with the human nature.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by taurath on Sunday July 02, 2017 @04:48AM (#14681568)
This is a troll comment, right? I'm can't really tell anymore (sign of the times).
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by thehardsphere on Sunday July 02, 2017 @08:30AM (#14682201)
Don't ever assume so. The amount of Marxism that runs rampant on Hacker News cannot be underestimated.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by noahth on Saturday July 01, 2017 @09:34PM (#14680274)
If you're working 12 hour days and having trouble with your social life, the problem is _not_ that it's not OK to hit on women in a professional setting. The problem is that you're working too much.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by theWatcher37 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:00PM (#14680388)
Stop bringing gender in to this. You can ask someone out during an after-hours social event without it being wrong.

What's wrong is retaliation based on those things happening.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by noahth on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:26PM (#14680502)
If you think I'm the one who brought gender into this, you're either ignorant to the structural realities of our industry, or you're willfully being obtuse. If it's the former, let me be the first to tell you that men have most of the power and it's no accident that in the story this post reacts to, it's the men in power committing the abuse and not the other way around. Not to say that women can't be inappropriate at work or whatever, but if you're looking to promote equality, "both sides do bad things" is not the right way to do it in this case.
Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by tnone on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:29AM (#14680905)
The structural realities of our industry are that men are the majority at all echelons. Men have most of the power and men are most of the subjects.

Ignoring half of the equation to paint women as a unique victim class is disingenuous, and ironically, it is a power move. Topping from the bottom.

HR taking the company's side... A superior leveraging their position to extract concessions rather than engage a person on equal ground... These are universal problems. Twisting everything into a gender issue because of sexuality involves the automatic assumption that a woman's sexual virtue is something special and any other abuse of power is just not as big a deal. A very gender essentialist and conservative position.

As an actual leftie, it should make me sad, but tbh it amuses me to no end in its absurdity. In the name of progressive politics, all sorts of traditional views are being promoted. Men should be chivalrous, women need protection, public shaming is good, morality must be enforced by a clerical class, with everyone else kissing the ring in acquiescence. Bizarre.

As if politics are far more built-in than we want to admit, and freedom and tolerance can become labels for the exact opposite.

Re:I'm a creep. I'm sorry by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:13AM (#14681018)
Are we demonising specific behaviours, or power imbalances in general, or just one gender?

Do exploitative power imbalances fade into political and economic background noise when they're "only" about money and/or hierarchy, and no dating or sex are involved?

Do "uncomfortable feelings" around dating and sex have a paradoxically privileged place in this discourse, over "uncomfortable feelings" caused by more overt forms of verbal, financial, political, or legal abuse - and if so, why?