News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Third Depression by mark_l_watson on Monday June 28, 2010 @08:55AM (#1467755)
I agree with you. The most important area to save money: we have military bases and/or installations in about 3/4 of the countries on this planet. We need to stop that. We also need to allow state and local governments to go through bankruptcy to renegotiate pensions, etc. Harsh, but necessary.

The easy copout is printing money.

Re:The Third Depression by gaius on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:39PM (#1468459)
Without a global presence it's questionable how long the USD would continue to be the world's reserve currency. If OPEC decides it'd rather trade in EUR then the USD goes into freefall and the US is pretty much screwed.
Re:The Third Depression by bwanab on Monday June 28, 2010 @01:23PM (#1468619)
There's no evidence to back up this assertion. Many economies that don't have reserve currency status do just fine (e.g. Switzerland, Norway, S.Korea). The expense of US overseas deployments far outweighs the benefit of having a militarily enforced reserve currency.
Re:The Third Depression by gaius on Monday June 28, 2010 @03:39PM (#1469162)
You're missing one key difference: Switzerland never had the overseas garrisons to start with. For the US not to, it will have to withdraw from them. That will be seen as a sign of underlying weakness. The strength of any currency is relative to the confidence that the government that operates it will continue to do what it does.

There's precedent: look at GBP as the UK dismantled its empire.

Re:The Third Depression by hga on Monday June 28, 2010 @11:34AM (#1468257)
The interest we're paying on Federal debt is or soon will equal the total US defense budget (or so the Chairman of the JCS recently noted).

You might also be really upset if the US returns to a pre-WWII isolationist mode (you do remember one of the things that happened as a result...). We keep the peace in large parts of the world and e.g. implicitly prevent a lot of those we're protecting from going nuclear.

The only thing less brutal than a Pax Romana, Britannia or America is its absence.

Re:The Third Depression by dantheman on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:16PM (#1468398)
Why? The US involvement in WWI led to the harshness of the Treaty of Versailles, if the US held back it's been argued that England and France would have sued for peace earlier and the harshness of the treaty wouldn't have been there and then one of the prime causes of WW2 would not have existed.

The Us involvement in WW2 is due to escapades in China and the Philippines - the reason Japan attacked the US.

Re:The Third Depression by hga on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:52PM (#1468505)
What are you arguing here?

The fact (well, I agree) that the US badly screwed up its first really major intervention in world affairs has little to do with the present day, unless you contend that we learned nothing from it (e.g. for WWII Unconditional Surrender and the occupation and nation building we did in Japan and West Germany).

Re:The Third Depression by dantheman on Monday June 28, 2010 @01:28PM (#1468647)
I'm arguing that non-intervention might be good; that perhaps interfering with other countries might not be a good idea. Now I'm all for humanitarian assistance, and helping people fleeing countries that are war torn. In fact, I think when their is serious strife the US should do it's best help people relocate to the US -- e.g. instead of letting people get slaughtered in Rwanda we should have helped evacuate them to the US.

I think that it is far from given that the US should be the world police, or that anyone should be the world police.