There's precedent: look at GBP as the UK dismantled its empire.
You might also be really upset if the US returns to a pre-WWII isolationist mode (you do remember one of the things that happened as a result...). We keep the peace in large parts of the world and e.g. implicitly prevent a lot of those we're protecting from going nuclear.
The only thing less brutal than a Pax Romana, Britannia or America is its absence.
The Us involvement in WW2 is due to escapades in China and the Philippines - the reason Japan attacked the US.
The fact (well, I agree) that the US badly screwed up its first really major intervention in world affairs has little to do with the present day, unless you contend that we learned nothing from it (e.g. for WWII Unconditional Surrender and the occupation and nation building we did in Japan and West Germany).
I think that it is far from given that the US should be the world police, or that anyone should be the world police.
The easy copout is printing money.