Re:Milestone: 100M Certificates Issued
by tialaramex on Friday June 30, 2017 @12:53PM
(#14671956)
Just making a certificate costs almost nothing. So in a sense $0 seems like the right price.
BUT, being _able_ to make certificates is very expensive. ISRG (the charity behind Let's Encrypt) spends _millions of dollars per year_ on this.
Purely mechanically Let's Encrypt needs a data centre with a bunch of high availability servers and pretty good Internet access, employees to look after all that stuff, a deal with CDNs to serve up their OCSP responses around the world (which ensure certificates stay working after they're issued) and so on, none of which is cheap and all of which needed to be in place before issuing even one certificate.
In practice to be any use the certificates need to be trusted, which meant meeting the standards of the big Trust Stores (definitely Apple, Microsoft, Mozilla, probably Google, Oracle, and ideally dozens more besides). Those standards require physical site security, regular third party audits, and so on, which cost even _more_.
Now, for Let's Encrypt the solution is this is a charity, you can pitch in $10 and if a hundreds of thousands of people like you do that then it all gets paid for, or if a few bigger organisations pitch in $1000 each that helps too.
But for a commercial outfit, well, why not charge $10 to cover costs? And if $10, why not $50? Why not $1000?
BUT, being _able_ to make certificates is very expensive. ISRG (the charity behind Let's Encrypt) spends _millions of dollars per year_ on this.
Purely mechanically Let's Encrypt needs a data centre with a bunch of high availability servers and pretty good Internet access, employees to look after all that stuff, a deal with CDNs to serve up their OCSP responses around the world (which ensure certificates stay working after they're issued) and so on, none of which is cheap and all of which needed to be in place before issuing even one certificate.
In practice to be any use the certificates need to be trusted, which meant meeting the standards of the big Trust Stores (definitely Apple, Microsoft, Mozilla, probably Google, Oracle, and ideally dozens more besides). Those standards require physical site security, regular third party audits, and so on, which cost even _more_.
Now, for Let's Encrypt the solution is this is a charity, you can pitch in $10 and if a hundreds of thousands of people like you do that then it all gets paid for, or if a few bigger organisations pitch in $1000 each that helps too.
But for a commercial outfit, well, why not charge $10 to cover costs? And if $10, why not $50? Why not $1000?