News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by 10ren on Sunday June 27, 2010 @10:11PM (#1466820)
Question: has anyone managed to do this? (eg. do hedge funds do this, or do they combine algorithms with their own ideas and quasi-insider knowledge, plus massive amounts of timely data - inaccessible to an individual).

My old supervisor (ACM fellow) comforted my failure to create AI by saying that lots of other clever people hadn't done it either. I have a feeling that you are attempting something more difficult that AI - ie, algorithmic inference without the data that your competitors have. Because of their better information, they will find a regularity (eg. 0.01% dip on Wednesdays) quicker than you - and trade it away.

It would be awesome if you could do it though - forget the philosopher's stone aspect of gold-for-nothing, this would be a very cool intellectual achievement.

Idea: focus on small markets/exchanges (unpopular metals, unpopular countries, even non-financial markets, like eBay) that don't attract the attention of big players. Easier to find arbitrage there; you can make some actual money, and then move onto a bigger market with your learnings, earnings, and confidence. Sort of a niche strategy.

Personal Note: My AI research depressed me, and I (wisely) decided to shelve it. It's been incredibly more satisfying to work with others, to achieve doable goals, that benefit others. Fortunately, AI comes up in everything; and my current approach (of not doing AI directly) may well be the most effective way to approach the goal. It might be the same with you - both markets and inference are universal.

EDIT So, Tantalus = low-hanging fruit + moving-goalposts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tantalus#Story_of_Tantalus

Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by pradocchia on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:22PM (#1468409)
Simply put, if anyone has managed to do it, you aren't likely to hear about it. That said, I know of two:

First was a math prof that would play the markets every couple years when he needed a little extra cash.

Second was someone who had isolated patterns of market intervention and figured out how to profit from them. But that's more like insider trading than beating the market algorithmically.