I have derived Black-Scholes; I study market micro-structure; I read as much as I can on anything related to social systems from volatility surfaces in options pricing to more generic machine learning methods such as PSO.
(I'd like to respond more, but I just noticed I am 20 minutes late for my fathers birthday party.)
On another note, betting markets are (or were) apparently far less efficient than financial markets, in that the true likelihood of a team/horse/camel winning in a competition may be different to the money which punters are willing to bet on it. I know of a guy who made his fortune after many gruelling years by finally coming up with prediction models which worked in these kind of gambling scenarios.
I'd love to read it, but the easiest way to answer your second question is to point you to 'A non random walk down wall street.'
One huge assumption that Black-Scholes makes is that returns are normal distributed. This is not done for empirical reasons rather mathematical ones, namely it is so convenient.
Edit: Pdf http://www.newyorkfed.org/research/conference/2007/liquidity...
Some meta data and such if you don't feel like going with a pdf:
I think your remark on finance professors is quite wrong. It takes quite a lot of dedication to do a Phd. I'm not great respecter of academic prestige, but its a bit insulting to imply that people fail their way into a professorship.
I'd be more than happy to share some pointers on financial papers I've read and such. Just talk about your background and what you know. If you think 'a random walk down Wall Street' is correct, it isn't. Have you seen the derivation of Black-Scholes? Do you know what most high frequency trading is based on?
I'd also be interested to see what type of stuff you like to read.