News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it possible to host Facebook on AWS? by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @08:08PM (#14659697)
...which gives you a moderately-expensive pile of laser-focused hardware and nothing to run on it. Far less than half the infrastructure story.

(Not that I'm criticizing Facebook. Open-sourcing code is hard -- see Borg.)

Re:Is it possible to host Facebook on AWS? by EGreg on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @08:31PM (#14659813)
Nothing to run on it??
Re:Is it possible to host Facebook on AWS? by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @10:13PM (#14660260)
Correct. "Infrastructure" means a lot of things. You don't get Tupperware, their scheduling and resource management infrastructure, most of their logging infra, most of their monitoring infra, operating systems for the whitebox hardware, even power and facilities management for the OC stuff... I could go on. They are quite good about releasing open source, which is why I was careful to point out that I'm not criticizing Facebook; open sourcing this stuff is really hard, because internal software develops tendrils to other internal things that you often don't want to open source.

The point was that yes, Open Compute exists, but its existence is only partially relevant when one claims that Facebook has opened their "infrastructure." The two sentences in GP are basically what I'm responding to -- mainly the verbatim "FB open sourced their infrastructure" -- and I guess the implied context of Facebook infrastructure was lost when I said "nothing to run on it," sorry. I meant Facebook code. So this is clear: Open Compute is good, and I'm appreciative of Facebook, just want to make sure we understand what "open infrastructure" means and its limitations in this case.

Re:Is it possible to host Facebook on AWS? by EGreg on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @11:36PM (#14660575)
Isn't there any software that would let you run your own social network like facebook on that hardware?
Re:Is it possible to host Facebook on AWS? by daxfohl on Thursday June 29, 2017 @12:10AM (#14660697)
Sure, you could write a social network app (or any other server-side app) and run it on that hardware. It just wouldn't take advantage of any of the Facebook-specific features on that hardware. So you'd be paying for a lot of stuff you're not using. For Facebook, it's more valuable to use it as Facebook hardware than to rent it out as generic servers, because Facebook actually uses all its proprietary features.