Although I am curious if anybody has counter-experience on this :D
I've noticed a bunch of friends either getting married or beginning serious LTRs after meeting online, though. They usually fall into two categories.
1. A set of mutual friends of them say "Hey, you two would be perfect for each other," introduce them, and then the relationship blooms through FaceBook or old-fashioned e-mail.
2. They're both participants at a "niche" online forum or social networking site, and then end up meeting in person eventually and take it from there.
I think the latter situation is way, way underreported. We pay attention to the big social sites like FaceBook and Twitter and the big dating sites like eHarmony and Match, but there's an enormous long-tail of niche sites that toss up a website and a forum and build a community. You can find a fansite for virtually every celebrity, every TV show, every sport, many of the more popular books, and even niche professional interests like startups and programming language design. Many of these grow very close, tight-knit communities, and when those communities are of mixed gender, it's very common for some dating to occur.
Heck, if HN weren't overwhelming male, I bet we'd see some Hacker News couples. There've already been a bunch of "Founder Dating" sites spun off from it.
We met when I searched Facebook for 'Cryptonomicon', and she was the only result. (This was April 2004, so there were maybe a couple thousand people on all of Facebook.)
We moved in together a few weeks later, and got married in 2006.
The swinger-ish nerdhemian folks I know who like OkCupid seem to use OkCupid as an alternative Facebook. One where they don't have to worry so much about their parents or not-so-close coworkers.
That's the most ridiculous phrase I've seen today. It also perfectly describes me 10 years ago :-)
They are silly folks but sometimes lots of fun.
I wanted to except some category of people, but I couldn't think of how to name the group without sounding judgmental. I agree with your sentiment.
Facebook has the unique, unbeatable advantage of being more evenly (more, outright?) female. Now we just have to get over the 'creepy/weird/scary' nuances of meeting people through non-traditional channels.
http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2010/04/07/why-you-should-...
Interesting points: * "you are 12.4 times more likely to get married this year if you don't subscribe to Match.com"
* the severe male/female imbalance ("sausage fest") leads to a "desperation feedback loop" where men spam more and more women, with fewer and fewer responses.
In my opinion, with the rise in social networking platforms, dating sites are dead or dying - at least for 'mainstream' use. Even OKCupid, I think, will be pointless as people learn to leverage Facebook for dating.