News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by jaclaz on Monday June 26, 2017 @03:33PM (#14639598)
With all due respect, it is not really a "free tool", it is seemingly a site where you have to sign up to get something.

This is also not particularly reassuring (I understand that being a beta it is probably only a temporary page copied from somewhere on the web):

https://minebaseapp.com/privacy

>Credit card information

We do not store your credit card information directly. It is passed through to a third party credit card processing merchant using 128-bit SSL encryption. We only keep your credit card's brand, last 4 digits and expiration date to assist and remind you of any billing related issues.

...

>Last updated April 1st 2042

Same goes for "Terms of Service":

https://minebaseapp.com/terms

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by detaro on Monday June 26, 2017 @04:03PM (#14639869)
Come on, requiring an account doesn't make something "not a free tool".
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by jaclaz on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @06:13AM (#14643836)
Mind you this is certainly NOT the case, the Author is seemingly a very nice chap and has all the good intentions in this world.

But "free" still means "free", and "tool" still means "tool".

It is not strictly speaking a "tool" it is some form of SaaS, you have to connect to that site, authenticate yourself, etc.

It is not "free" the sheer moment it asks (indirectly, through your e-mail address) your identification.

That there is "nothing bad" in it is another thing.

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by Sir_Substance on Monday June 26, 2017 @05:45PM (#14640648)
It doesn't have to make it "not a free tool", but in my experience it often does. Why even bother with an account system? Nothing on the front page of this site suggests an account is technically necessary.

Yet the owner of the site is presumably paying for a DB to store all this information. Why?

Usually there is one of two answers:

A) They want to sell you shit, and they need some kind of identifier they can use to unlock content

B) They want to collect info on you to sell to other people

Either way, that's not free. If it's A, I am being asked to invest time in a tool without being told it's potential limitations (there's nothing on the front page mentioning limitations on unpaid accounts), and that's a cost.

If it's B, I'm being data-mined, and companies only pay for data-mining if they think they can turn it into more profit, data-mining costs included. So if I'm being data-mined, it's because someone thinks they can use that data to get me to part with more money at some point down the line than I would choose to part with sans manipulation. That's a cost.

Of course, there's always option C) The site creator hasn't thought about why they need an account system, and made one because that's what all the other cool websites do.

Usually when C comes into play, you can expect account data leakages to follow due to piss poor security practices, and that's a cost.

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by sillysaurus3 on Monday June 26, 2017 @05:56PM (#14640723)
It's easier to throttle people if you have to use an account to access the information.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by Sir_Substance on Monday June 26, 2017 @06:36PM (#14640988)
> It's easier to throttle people if you have to use an account to access the information.

That's not true in the slightest. I can create as many accounts as I can have email addresses, and I can have as many email addresses as I want.

Robust throttling _requires_ an alternative throttling mechanism that works independent of account information, otherwise I can round-robin between accounts to bypass all throttling.

If you're gonna have that anyway, we're back to "no technical need for accounts".

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by iEchoic on Monday June 26, 2017 @09:37PM (#14641927)
> Robust throttling _requires_ an alternative throttling mechanism that works independent of account information

If they use Facebook login instead of email, how do you plan on getting thousands of Facebook accounts?

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by Sir_Substance on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @05:15AM (#14643564)
A) They didn't require facebook login

B) It's been a while since I last checked, but I don't believe there's anything stopping me from just making shittonnes of facebook accounts

C) Facebook accounts are about 90c each, if you're desperate: https://buyaccs.com/en/buy-bulk-facebook-accounts.php

Accounts are not a throttling mechanism. In and of themselves, they cannot be.

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by hobbescotch on Monday June 26, 2017 @05:56PM (#14640722)
Account system reduces the amount of people bypassing the 1 concurrent export per person limit (although I could do more on this front). I used this site so I can get a job coding since I'm an English Lit major who doesn't want to spend more money on school, which, thankfully, has recently paid off as I'm starting a new position next month. Also, $10 a month isn't a lot to pay for a fun project that will (maybe) help a bunch of people, but I can understand the suspicion.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by Sir_Substance on Monday June 26, 2017 @06:37PM (#14640995)
>Account system reduces the amount of people bypassing the 1 concurrent export per person limit (although I could do more on this front).

It doesn't do that at all, see here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14640988

Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by swiley on Monday June 26, 2017 @04:50PM (#14640246)
The "SSL" cryptographic operator is generally secure when used with 128-bit keys.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by hobbescotch on Monday June 26, 2017 @03:39PM (#14639650)
To be honest, I just took a boilerplate privacy statement, but you're right, I should have checked that first and removed that bit.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by jaclaz on Monday June 26, 2017 @03:50PM (#14639737)
Yep, and please do change/correct the date, as is it does seem like an April Fool's day (in the future).
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by hobbescotch on Monday June 26, 2017 @04:08PM (#14639914)
Fixed!
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by nik736 on Monday June 26, 2017 @04:48PM (#14640228)
Not for me.
Re:Minebase: a free data mining tool for social networks by an27 on Monday June 26, 2017 @05:21PM (#14640499)
Maybe his reply came from the future?

(It's also still 2042 for me.)