Because that "team" did, in fact, lose something - at least in relation to the very cynical (and probably correct) charge that minimum wage increases are vote-buying.
Also, I think it's worth considering that the very sound and considerable notion that "a wage price floor causes all other prices to catch up" is probably lumped right in with "the government collects the same amount of revenue at this point on the curve as on this point of the curve"[1][2]. Since that "team" is vehemently opposed to the Laffer Curve it's not surprising that they'd be vehemently opposed to other "voo doo economics".
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhiCFdWeQfA (jump to :37)
What I was trying to say was: "people who think (that team) is losing might be having a knee-jerk response to a (mistaken) link in their own minds between wage price floor theories and supply side economic theories".
No, I don't think they are the only two options and further I don't think they are related at all.
(it's an elegant illustration, but to implement policy concrete estimates of impacts on revenues are more useful than an elegant illustration)
I can't say that I agree with you, but you're generally a thoughtful guy and I would appreciate getting another perspective on the issue.
(Also, curious: is the word "national" operative there -- eg, do your beliefs differ between a national minimum wage and a local one like the Seattle measure?)
I definitely don't oppose the minimum wage! There's no libertarianism creeping into my perspective here. :)
Full disclosure: if it were up to me, we would go with either a flat tax or something more sensible that an economist has proposed (i.e. Friedman's negative income tax). But that would, of course, largely abolish the need for the IRS and the thousands of jobs tied to figuring out taxes each year. In other words, I am definitely more keen on a strong vector toward Libertarianism.
An extreme case would be that someone who earned a billion dollars and paid a 99.9% tax on it would still be much better off than someone who earned 16K and paid a negative 1% rate.
The starting premise is that taxes should be judged based on how they impact your quality of life, not on how much quantity of money they take.
Logically then, progressive taxes are better.
This is a widely debated topic that usually devolves into an argument about whether property is some sort of natural right or if it is a societal construct. Even on the natural rights side of the argument you will find adherents that believe any taxation is a violation of their natural rights.
I'm pretty uninterested in traveling the paths of Hobbes and Kant on an internet forum, so suffice it to say that its pretty clear to most people that there is a societal benefit to taxes and a societal desire to make those "fair". Arguing over what is more fair is unlikely to be resolved by logical proof but a lot of people think quality of life impact is the fair option.
* I support higher taxes, particularly on higher income people, almost for its own sake.
* I oppose almost all military intervention abroad.
* I believe the federal government needs to intervene with local governments to prevent police abuses.
* I strongly support public schools and oppose public-funded charters.
... and I could go on and on this way.
On the other hand, I do not believe in a high national minimum wage, or in a small number of other "liberal" orthodoxies^h^h^h^h^hidees fixes (like universal college tuition, or single-payer health care).
Why am I meant to feel like my "team" lost something when a study confirms something that most economists have been saying for decades?