News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber’s Complicit Board by TeMPOraL on Monday June 26, 2017 @04:42AM (#14635090)
After all the current mess gets resolved and the dust settles down (hopefully with Uber kicking the calendar), we'll still need to have a serious conversation about how was this allowed to happen in the first place.

Uber built their business on utter disregard for the rule of law. In the process, they highlighted just how poor - or unwilling - local governments are at enforcing their own rules. This needs to get fixed, hopefully before the next wave of "laws are for losers" "entrepreneurs" hits.

Re:Uber’s Complicit Board by x0x0 on Monday June 26, 2017 @05:27AM (#14635316)
The taxis, in sf at least, are pieces of human shit. I had a badly broken leg (multiple surgeries, 10 months on crutches including a reinjury) and they were horrible to me, even though I took 8-10 cabs/week. So I was deeply grateful for uber because -- and this is a miracle compared to sf taxis -- they actually came, or if they weren't going to, they told you! That's it! I was willing to pay 2-3x just for that. SF taxis: "we'll be there in 15 minutes", which was utterly unrelated to arrival time and destroyed your ability to plan your day at all.

I've put these stats on here before, but even though I called a taxi every day to go to work -- stats are in an xlx not on this laptop, so this is approximate -- the 80% wait time was approximately an hour, for someone who lived at 22/valencia and wanted to go to soma. And they regularly just didn't show up ever. Or threw tantrums if I didn't shoot down two flights of stairs, but it was totally cool for them to come an hour after being called. And the card readers 'broke' all the time -- but when you refuse to go to an atm and tell them their choice is to take a card or take $0, lo it's a miracle! The card machine starts working! I had more than one driver get pissy they weren't tipped after they tried to make me crutch over to an atm to pay them. Or one who didn't start the meter and tried to charge me $30-ish for a ride that normally cost $16.

Oh, and try getting a cab Thurs or Fri night to go home.

It's particularly amazing that a government sponsored monopoly would treat the handicapped this way.

In conclusion, fuck yellow cab in particular, but also fuck green cab and arrow. This is why no-one cared that uber ran a taxi service. Because it was ludicrously better.

I stuck with Uber for a long time because they made my life work for the second half of the injury, but finally switched to lyft 6 months ago.

Re:Uber’s Complicit Board by TeMPOraL on Monday June 26, 2017 @08:23AM (#14636174)
One thing that I realized in the recent Uber threads, by reading stories such as yours, is that regular taxis in the US (in particular in SF and NYC) must really, really suck. I can understand the popularity of Uber there, if things were really as bad as it seems from reading HN. Maybe taxi regulations in the States are really that broken.

But at some point, Uber expanded overseas, and took their laissez-faire attitude to regulations to places where taxis were kind of OK, and the laws were reasonable. That behaviour is much less forgivable there - because there isn't even a fig leaf of civil disobedience to hide behind, it's obvious money grab through anticompetitive behaviour.

Re:Uber’s Complicit Board by potatolicious on Monday June 26, 2017 @06:00AM (#14635479)
Agreed, though I hope that any serious post-mortem about the Uber debacle include not just the regulatory failure that led to Uber's abuses, but also the regulatory failure that led to Uber's existence in the first place.

Part of why local governments were unwilling to enforce the law against Uber was because the citizenry wanted the Uber product, and wanted it badly. The pace at which Uber grew is not just indicative of the absurd funding they had, but also how broken the status quo was in the taxi industry.

Local governments were largely unable to enforce the rule of law in this area because the law-abiding option had become utterly and completely indefensible.

In Seattle there were popular protests in favor of Uber, that's how badly the product was wanted.

I think there's a larger lesson here about poor governance being corrosive to the rule of law - at the end of the day, if things get bad enough, the law becomes words on a page rather than the rule of the land. That's a scary thought.

The taxi industry pre-Uber was universally reviled. Many comments here illustrate it, and they're not wrong. Strict supply limits created a market where competition was all but unnecessary, while would-be competitors had no legal ability to operate.

My (admittedly simplified) take is this: years of complete regulatory and governance failure around for-hire cabs created fertile ground for companies cavalier or dismissive about transport law. Companies cavalier or dismissive about transport law turn out to be cavalier or dismissive about other areas of law, to no particular surprise. While Uber can and should be held to account for all of its abuses, another Uber (or worse) will simply reoccur unless the underlying governance failure is fixed.

Re:Uber’s Complicit Board by TeMPOraL on Monday June 26, 2017 @10:30AM (#14637064)
I don't know why you were downvoted. I totally agree. FWIW, Uber's activities did highlight quite a lot of things that were wrong with taxis - especially in the US, from what I hear (not that taxis in Europe are perfect, but I don't see that many horror stories about them).

> I think there's a larger lesson here about poor governance being corrosive to the rule of law - at the end of the day, if things get bad enough, the law becomes words on a page rather than the rule of the land. That's a scary thought.

Yeah, and that's why I blame local governments for a lot in this debacle. It's their job to make sure a) laws make sense, and b) laws get enforced. Uber should be held responsible for a lot of things, but that's orthogonal to the fact that so far they really haven't been, and allowing that is damaging to the very perception of the rule of law.