Re:TL;DR: This Meme Must Die
by jonpaul on Friday June 25, 2010 @11:55PM
(#1463058)
TL;DR
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:TL;DR: This Meme Must Die
by kevinherron on Saturday June 26, 2010 @12:03AM
(#1463072)
You see, this is the intended use; in this context it makes sense.
In the context in which you are providing a summary you are saying "I read this, and for those of you who think "TL;DR" here is a summary..."
agreed. TL;DR by itself actually makes sense. It means something distinct from, "in summary: <blah>".
That's funny! :) I guess I should have made the article shorter so you could have gotten to the very end of it, which was:
Summary: TL;DR Sucks, Summary is Better
Re:TL;DR: This Meme Must Die
by joe_the_user on Saturday June 26, 2010 @12:03AM
(#1463071)
I agree with the parent ...
More so,
If hn is worth anything, it somewhat reasonable dialog. This particular response just oozes dismissiveness and a willingness to toss out discussion.
Yep, "too long / didn't read" has a negative vibe, it's both dismissive and a little insulting to the author of the target piece. Plus, it makes the person saying it look a little lazy or lacking the ability to focus and read through anything longer than a sound bite.
"Summary: <whatever>" is nice because it is impersonal and provides a useful service to other readers. Here is a brief summary of what the piece is about. Useful and not impolite.
(--btw, I'm the author of the "This Meme Must Die" article being discussed, Synisma)