News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by analog31 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:20AM (#14629854)
I play an "obsolete" instrument, the double bass. And I play jazz. So my gut reaction is: Welcome to the club.

Electric guitar (and electric bass) enjoyed their day in the sun, and it was well deserved. When the Fender guitar came on the scene, a dance band required as many as 19 musicians, all playing instruments that took years of training just to even make a decent sound, much less to play at a performance level.

The electric guitar and bass had a much different learning curve (not better or worse, like C vs Python) and 3 or 4 musicians could take the place of 19. Of course changing musical styles played a role in this transition as well, so I'm really over-simplifying here. The simpler harmonic structure of songs made it easier to crank out hits, and the manipulation of electronic effects allowed the creation of new styles such as hard rock, heavy metal, and so forth.

Rock music also had a certain social appeal. As opposed to taking lessons and then sitting at home and practicing scales, you joined a bunch of friends, and all learned together in the absence of any adult supervision. Many bands create new songs together by trial and error. Styles and songs were learned by ear -- the folk music tradition, which certainly has its own historical precedent.

It couldn't last forever. Fifty years is a pretty darn good run. New instruments have emerged, with their own learning curve and cultural appeal. That's great. Meanwhile, playing an obsolete instrument can still have its own attractions.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by zwieback on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:55AM (#14629978)
Finally bought an upright after years of playing bass guitar. Couldn't be happier but transport is a pain. Still play the bass guitar, though, I don't think anything is going obsolete, half of the electric guitars people bought in it's golden years were just collecting dust anyway.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by a_bevin on Sunday June 25, 2017 @03:50PM (#14631815)
You might enjoy this lightweight upright electric bass. I've performed with the creator of this bass for the past 7 years and it always sounds great and can be carried around very conveniently. http://www.kyddbass.com/models.htm
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by scarecrowbob on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:17AM (#14630083)
I play upright (I'm actually getting ready to go my gig for today).

I dunno if it helps, but when I started I did not know I could put it in the front seat of most cars with the seat laid back. That's made transport relatively easy ( though it is a very bulky instrument).

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by analog31 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @11:43AM (#14630519)
I had a compact sedan for a long time, and can confirm your observation. In fact, it worked best for me to feed the bass into the driver's side rear door (of a 4-door car), scroll first, and then upside down in the passenger seat.

Now I have a little hatchback, and am quite happy. Granted, transportation is still an issue -- I'm floored when I hear about bassists getting around in NYC using cabs, the subway, etc. But it's the only instrument that I play well enough for anybody to actually want me to play it, and I do love the bass.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by zwieback on Sunday June 25, 2017 @02:34PM (#14631414)
A guy I know squeezes his homemade mando-bass (still a large instrument) into a Karman Ghia. Only he knows the magic twists and turns to get it in and out.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by joshuata on Sunday June 25, 2017 @06:19PM (#14632525)
I had an old 86 Honda CRX (two seater), and figured out how to fit my bass, amp, and two cellos. I'm pretty sure I couldn't do it again. The main trick, though, is to recline the passengers seat and sit the bass in it.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday June 25, 2017 @11:06AM (#14630301)
I have seen a double bass player with a homemade teardown instrument that was claimed to fit into an overhead bin.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by analog31 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @11:40AM (#14630497)
Well, fortunately or unfortunately for me, I'm not good enough to get called on a fly gig, but there's some priceless pictures in Rufus Reid's The Evolving Bassist on how to load a bass into an airline seat. I doubt that's still possible today.