Edit: Ok so I installed Beta, and it asks you on initial setup page if you want to enable or disable all iCloud and macOS services (respectively, they are completely separated options). That's cool!
For something that would "disable everything by default" I would simply like to get a GlassWire-like +1 notification on the icon, and then I should be able to see a list of "last blocked" so I can troubleshoot myself later if something went wrong.
Its nothing new though. Layer-7 firewalls ("personal firewalls") have existed for desktop OSes for a while. I ran them in end of 90s on Windows 9x. Software such as ZoneAlarm, and there were others as well (IIRC LavaSoft had one, but not sure). Nowadays, Windows has one build-in.
I don't know how you imagine this would work. If I load up a GitHub PR in my browser and then swap to my editor, will the page update when I get a review comment 30 minutes later? If I launch a program and it immediately phones home, is that blocked?
Yes.
> I don't know how you imagine this would work.
That's why I'd like Little Snitch to figure it out. There will be judgment calls, edge cases, and decisions. If there's anyone capable of doing it, it's the developers of Little Snitch.
I don't see a theoretical reason why we can't have "maximum privacy while user initiated outbound still works" -- for some reasonable definition of those words.
That's trivial to do with little snitch.
It's not trivial unless you have a lot of network, sysadmin, and OS X background. You have to think about a lot of issues of what to permit, what to deny. Then you still get alerts and have to research the things that want access.
I'm reluctant to deny unfamiliar system apps in case I break something and later have to spend a half a day tracking down mysterious behavior.
The developers of Little Snitch have this knowledge. They could create presets for common situations.
The only preset I want is "maximum privacy while user initiated outbound still works". I'd be satisfied even with cookbook step-by-step instructions for such a preset.
Using little snitch to "Deny All except Safari Outbound" is exactly the same as working offline, except that your web browser now works. No Networks/Sysadmin/OS X experience required. By and large, the largest and most annoying culprits on my systems are the OS X system utilities doing background updates, syncing photos, etc.... Ironically, they are the ones I most want to shut down when I'm not on home WiFi.
Plus, if you have 15-30 minutes one afternoon, it's a great way to get insight into what your system is doing, and gain some (small) amount of comfort that you know what's going in/out of your system. Well, that is, everything that isn't bypassing the kernel in the first place.... :-(
One preset that I would love is "maximum privacy while user initiated outbound still works". So my browser would work because I initiated it, but everything OSX or apps do in the background are blocked. Automatic updates are blocked? Good! Network time sync is blocked? Fine by me. Only what I initiate gets through. Can you do that as a preset please?
Did they do that?
Seriously, I love the idea of a reverse firewall, but I don't want more work to do. I don't want to analyze connections, look at visualizations, read logs, react to alerts, set up filters, and configure rules.
I just want a high security, maximum privacy system.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13443858