Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone
by mistermann on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:51PM
(#14630894)
> Japan's cultural uniqueness is mostly a romantic myth
Have you been there? I can't imagine anyone who has spent any amount of time in Japan would claim there is no cultural uniqueness.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone
by krapp on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:05PM
(#14632727)
I may have just been imprecise in my wording. I was addressing andreiw's assertion that Japan would "not really (be) Japan anymore" after cultural influence from immigration. But Japan's culture is already the beneficiary of a great deal of foreign cultural influence, so nothing would happen to it with respect to immigration that hasn't been happening to it since practically the dawn of time.
At best, the rate of cultural transformation might be accelerated, but even then I suspect the doomsday scenario of Japan simply vanishing in a generation (or whatever) due to an influx of immigrants is unlikely. If the Meiji restoration or the American occupation didn't destroy Japan's cultural identity then a few thousand more gaijin won't either.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone
by andreiw on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:37AM
(#14630179)
Why would the loss of ethnic identity in Japan not be a bad thing? It would be a loss for diversity.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone
by krapp on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:56PM
(#14632933)
It would be a gain for diversity in Japan, though. These things are relative.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone
by andreiw on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:41PM
(#14633662)
Confused. On a planetary scale, it would result in a net loss of diversity. Let's take it to the extreme and claim the Japanese completely die out as an ethnic group. Why would the diversity increase?
Japan would lose its ethnic homogeneity, but to me that's not something worth caring about or mourning the loss of. The culture would change, but culture always changes.