Re:The Master's Voice: What we know of Bach, and may never c...
by jancsika on Saturday June 24, 2017 @06:13PM
(#14627699)
> It definitely has 'charm.'
That's actually a good example of what the author is (probably) talking about.
The link you gave takes Bach's originally 3/4 setting of the melody and "decompresses" it by stretching it to fit in 4/4 time. The cover version multiplies the duration of the first note of each measure by two. That gives the melody a more lyrical, singing quality.
Also, the imitative countermelody of the bass is removed and replaced with a more regular guitar accompaniment.
That's actually a good example of what the author is (probably) talking about.
The link you gave takes Bach's originally 3/4 setting of the melody and "decompresses" it by stretching it to fit in 4/4 time. The cover version multiplies the duration of the first note of each measure by two. That gives the melody a more lyrical, singing quality.
Also, the imitative countermelody of the bass is removed and replaced with a more regular guitar accompaniment.
Hence, charm. :)