News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by lucideer on Thursday June 22, 2017 @06:21PM (#14615756)
The overwhelmingly negative response from the primarily US-based HN audience to this, in stark contrast to the very positive responses from actual recipients of contact in this initiative (and the subsequent extremely positive and progressive election turnout statistics) are surely symptomatic of some significant fundamental differences in the perception of politics in both countries.

I appear to be literally the only person in this thread who thinks this is OK. As someone who's largely opposed to advertising full stop, in any form, this doesn't seem the same to me in any way. Nor can I see any reason to find it objectionable.

What exactly is it about this that makes people uncomfortable?

Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by dwaltrip on Thursday June 22, 2017 @07:36PM (#14616104)
Well, it would be much better if the article wasn't written by those who organized the efforts. They are likley to be heavily biased towards interpreting the outcome positively, especially in a public write up. They could have somewhat alleviated this concern with hard data, but unfortunately they did not do so.

For me, it's pretty simple. I don't like it for the same reason that I don't like door-to-door solicitors or activists.

Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by lucideer on Friday June 23, 2017 @05:45AM (#14618007)
This is a fair point. I would like to see hard data.

While I'm based in Ireland, I do know a good deal of people in the UK who voted and campaigned (and one who ran for LibDems), and we are also quite close and clued in to UK politics here in general. To me, their account seems plausible based on my own anecdotal knowledge of how campaigning during the election went.

The youth vote turnout was unprecedented, and there was a lot of people involved in various "weird", innovative grass-roots voluntary political campaigns for Corbyn.

In that sense, it felt very Sanders-esque, so the reference to Clinton in the article is bizarre. Particularly given the almost universal, blatant anti-Corbyn media bias. This may also be another reason it seems OK - Clinton/other political campaigns have big media behind them (and large financial interests), so I don't think it would work for them. People wouldn't be as willing to volunteer their time for such an industry-backed cause. Corbyn, like Sanders was very much demonized by the media (tbh, probably worse than for Sanders), so this may seem more like fighting back to people involved (both the senders and receivers of the messages).

Point taken on the door-to-door solicitors or activists, but that depends on the cause really too I think. Certainly most people despise commercial door-to-door calls, but I personally do door-to-door political canvassing here in Ireland, which is the norm here and in the UK, and the vast majority of feedback is positive. Nobody minds when its politics.

[dead]
Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by qbrass on Thursday June 22, 2017 @08:04PM (#14616222)
More likely, there was already a bunch of people on Tinder trolling people for fun, who came across this and wanted in on the deal so they could troll people and get paid for it.
Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by lucideer on Friday June 23, 2017 @05:29AM (#14617963)
I perhaps misread the article - I didn't see the part where it said these people were paid? I was under the impression they were all volunteers, no?
Re:How Tinder could take back the White House by qbrass on Friday June 23, 2017 @07:07AM (#14618286)
The quote was about people showing interest when they learned what was going on, not the people working for them.

By the time you find out they're not getting paid, you've already expressed enough interest to have someone use you as an example of someone wanting to join them.