Then the local government comes in and says that they are the only store allowed in town.
Now, is it fair to General Mills that they have to compete with the store brand cereal when the store brand is effectively free and there is no way for General Mills to get their cereal to you any other way?
But the FCC doesn't have that authority and it's a nonstarter in congress. So the stop gap is to force the government granted monopolies to play nice as a condition of their monopoly status.
https://s22.postimg.org/lilkrmo4x/Screen_Shot_2017-06-21_at_...
What do you think your chances of competing against Facebook, or Facebook-based businesses, are, when clients see this before accessing your site?
It's a huge, huge fallacy to claim "this thing would happen regardless, so who cares how difficult we make it for it to happen". Your mind is wrong.
I'm proud of India for rejecting Zuckerberg's ploy, and I wish Peru was wise enough to do the same.
Right now is like a public road, with free and equal access for every body, and thus, an economy can be built around it. If you change it to the store model, it morphs from an economy to a business, and businesses are not capable of supporting an entire economy built on top, so it won't.
My actual point is, analogies just don't work.
The grocery store analogy doesn't work. The road or electric grid analogies are perfectly apt.
And actually, I think an unusual answer is:
Grocery stores kind of suck, actually. I know I'm not able to get the best need/product fit, because of all the presentation that goes into it (display case arrangement, psychology of product locations...).
You can pay the grocery store to make me think your product is better, instead of having a better product. You also have to get your product into the grocery store in the first place, which is a serious hurdle.
On the other hand, 90% of everything is crap, and you actually need special skills to navigate the free-for-all street markets... which still have a lot of the same problems.
Under such a view, it's not that NN is great, it's that everything else (that's known) is worse.
The real answer is they're really not analogous enough to compare this way, even if comparing them yields interesting thoughts.
ISPs are like mail services: a letter is a letter is a letter. A package is a package is a package. And a packet is a packet is a packet.
Why is it bad that ISPs charge us based on type/source of data? Should grocery stores charge us by volume (mass?) of food instead of by type/source/etc? If aggregating costs is indeed more moral, why should it be enforced by law (as opposed to the food example)?
Providing robust answers to these questions should strengthen the NN position.