If an organization is doing 802.1x, competently manages its endpoints (this is a tiny, tiny fraction of "managed" Windows sites), etc then maybe a BeyondCorp-style architecture is a net loss of security.
If an attacker can waltz into a conference room or exploit some salesperson's IE6 and start making requests from the "secure" network, probably best to make it obvious that there is no secure network.
It's hard enough to get them to adopt IPv6 since most think NAT is essential for security. "But my address is world reachable!" Face palm...
The first couple BeyondCorp papers talk a lot about how Google deployed this architecture side-by-side their traditional LAN, and slowly migrated applications over, only after closely inspecting and understanding the traffic.
But the real point they make is that Internet != safe = very much worry about security.
How is the latter going to be less secure than opening up your entire LAN to everyone who needs to access a single resource?
If you have interactive session audting.....you will be hearing from me.
Our first priority in developing our bastion product was to guarantee end-to-end privacy and verifiability, so the cleartext is not available on any bastion. We do have a roadmap item to support customers' desire for visibility into team activity, but we engineered for privacy first. Our current auditing is event-based - device enrolled, credential issued, ssh/rdp login, etc.
Happy to discuss our roadmap further - [email protected]
The most common feedback I get is that it seems like too much of a stretch for companies that don’t operate at Google scale. That may be true if looking at the system as a whole, but the principles behind the architecture should attract anyone’s attention - remove trust from the network by authenticating and authorizing every request based on what’s known about the user and connecting device at the time of the request.
Disclaimer: I work for ScaleFT, a provider of Zero Trust access management solutions.
Edit: If folks are interested in hearing more about how other companies can achieve something similar, here's video of a talk I gave at Heavybit a few months ago on the subject: https://www.heavybit.com/library/blog/beyondcorp-meetup-goog...