News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How is Ruby different in Japan? by int_19h on Tuesday June 20, 2017 @02:10PM (#14597006)
It depends on what you're trying to do. It's pretty common with strings to ask for "everything excluding the first and the last character", for example, and then you want the end index (counted backwards), not length. Another common case is when you looked up a substring and got an index, and now you're slicing the string around that index.

But there are also many cases where length is more desirable.

Ditto with ranges - both end-inclusive and end-exclusive ranges are useful in different cases. I kinda like the fact that Ruby lets you choose, but I think that .. vs ... syntax distinction is too subtle and likely to cause bugs.

I kinda like the way Nim does it: .. for inclusive, and ..< for exclusive - e.g. 1..<10. They also use special syntax for count-from-end, instead of negative indices, which is also a good thing IMO (the decision to index from start or from end is usually something that's not going to change at runtime; but with negative indexing, it might inadvertently do so if you underflow when computing the index).

There are no comments on this comment yet.