Objections to a "xxx" TLD seem to fall into one of two categories: That there is no way to decide which sites should be given a "xxx" domain, and that there is no way to enforce a "xxx" domain. As far as I know, there is no current plan to legislate the "xxx" domain so it would seem that it wouldn't matter. Even as an opt-in for self categorization, it can only help to make the purpose of a site more clear. Even if not universally used, it makes it a little easier to both find and avoid pornography. Chances are that what gets put under the "xxx" domain will eventually be decided organically. Personally, I think that it's likely that businesses who's explicit purpose is selling sexual content will begin to use it and websites which contain pornography only incidentally will likely avoid it.
Re:.xxx to be a reality soon?
by techiferous on Thursday June 24, 2010 @08:12PM
(#1459583)
"some already existing TLDs were just absurd"
My favorite is .um, for U.S. minor outlying islands, population 300. It was, um, discontinued.
But why .xxx instead of .porn or .sex? If you want a TLD jsut for porn, then you might as well call it that.
Well other "extreme" things like violence or gore could conceivably be expected under .xxx but not .porn
Agree though that the ever increasing number of TLD suffixes is a bit of a joke. (I think it's a scam to get more money from people, mostly, at this point.)
> Well other "extreme" things like violence or gore could conceivably be expected under .xxx but not .porn
I see that as an argument in favour of .porn.
Re:.xxx to be a reality soon?
by chasingsparks on Thursday June 24, 2010 @08:17PM
(#1459590)
Just history, I think: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-rated#United_States
.xxx conforms nicely to most users expectations of a three letter TLD.
(Although, I agree -- it's a legislative nightmare.)