They took a risk, and it paid off. In my opinion, C# is both a better language and has better class libraries.
As for better class libraries, I found the .NET BCL to be excellently designed and thought through. It's also very consistent throughout. Now, parts of the FCL, like System.Windows.Forms are another matter ...
There's still some warts, such as there not being an ISet<T> before .NET 4, but Java's standard library has its share of quirks and historical weirdnesses as well. And as libraries age there are always old ways of doing things you can never really remove, and newer ways that are better. None of the two is as bad as C++, but depending on what you do you can stumble around in a swamp of old APIs for a while before finding what you're actually supposed to use.
Look at C# on the other hand and you see they had to add entirely new types which means that the .NET framework has an ugly split between APIs based on the old container classes and those based on the new container classes. That fits the trend that C# is a better language than Java, but Java has better class libraries to work with.