That said, work environment often has some kind of time constraint. If one can't solve any of the (simple, abstract, representative) problems that I pose within a 2hour time frame, it is possible that they are not a good match. And unfortunately, I rarely have the leisure to hire someone for a month to prove otherwise.
[from a comment of yours below]
> You're right about that particular exercise. I kind of used it to make a more general point.
That may be true for others, but my interview questions are all of this mold: abstract, with a short and simple (but not trick-required-here) solution, close to (an abstract version of) a real world "business problem".
I agree that technical interview questions (much like many aspects of life) put the wrong kind of stress on some and puts them at a disadvantage. But, and I always ask this[0], what alternative do you suggest?
[0] The answers so far have been essentially either "no idea", "let me prove to you on my terms" (which, when broken down, is rarely economical for either side or at all possible), or "just trust me on this"; I find none of them satisfying.
In many ways, writing on the Internet is much like the interviews we are discussing, especially in a place such as this, which has so many highly opinionated experts. I get why you got hostile responses to your post, but I also get what the reason for writing that post was. In person, the exact same words would not have lead to such a high-strung feeling as one gets when posting about anything controversial on the Internet.
On the Internet, if you go out on a limb, someone will always cut the branch.
The thing about such things is I know I can do it. But maybe it'll take 5 minutes, or maybe an hour. Maybe I'd attempt to do it differently given an unfamiliar scenario for which to be doing this in the first place; maybe I've never done this specific task in this specific language, and I'll take some extra minutes figuring out how pointers or references work in the language I'm using in the test. Maybe I've recently enjoyed some momentum on high level concepts (i.e. I produced software that fulfills a business need) and it'll take me a while to refocus my attention on low level implementations.
Engaging one's brain carries some very variable overheads. If you just give me 5 minutes and watch me write every single line of code and comment about it while I'm doing it, then it's just not going to happen.