News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by grellas on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:11PM (#1456757)
A few comments on this summary judgment ruling:

1. The decision came at the trial-court level and is not binding on other courts (though it might be persuasive). It is a summary judgment, meaning that the judge decided it before a trial could be held based on affidavits submitted by the parties. This also means that it will be easier to reverse on appeal than would a decision after trial.

2. The decision puts the burden on a copyright holder to identify item-by-item each claimed instance of copyright infringement and to report it under the DMCA. It leaves the hosting party in a position of being able to ignore what may or may not be infringing on its site so long as it responds promptly and faithfully to take-down notices for specific items.

3. The court sharply distinguished precedents concerning sites that had facilitated P2P copying, concluding that those cases had nothing to do with the DMCA safe harbor. Viacom had obviously played up those cases, essentially arguing that the defendants here profited from the regular and widespread posting of infringing materials on the YouTube site and therefore should be guilty of some form of contributory infringement liability. The court stiff-armed all such arguments by saying, in effect, "no, that's all different - Google's sole obligation here was to comply with DMCA and, if it did, it can't be held liable as a contributory infringer."

4. The court also dismissed the idea that Google could be held liable for not doing wholesale take-downs upon receiving a general notice that broad categories of materials on its site were potentially infringing (in essence, holding that a hosting site cannot possibly be in a position to determine what truly is or is not infringing just because it falls in some category or other of materials that might be infringing). Thus, the court refused to interpret DMCA in a way that puts the hosting party in a position where it must actively monitor its site for offending materials apart from its obligation to respond to specific take-down requests.

5. What is really involved here is a policy dispute over the safe-harbor protections of DMCA: Google says it is enough that it complies with take-down requests; Viacom says Google should still be liable if widespread posting of infringing material is regularly going on and if Google is profiting from that activity.

6. Though the judge did not make formal mention of it in his decision, it cannot have helped Viacom that it appears to have had dirty hands in this mess, in part by having its own agents upload a good number of the allegedly offending materials to the site. This sort of conduct really stinks of a setup and prompt judges to shape their formal legal reasoning in a way that reflects their disapproval of such misconduct.

7. On a final note, summary judgments are notoriously difficult to uphold on appeal and so this will be appealed and the outcome of that appeal will be anybody's guess. Therefore, an important victory for Google but by no means any sort of final one.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by ecuzzillo on Thursday June 24, 2010 @12:53AM (#1457340)
General legal question: If you're a judge, you presumably think you're right, and so you'd want your rulings to be upheld. So, if it's harder to appeal after-trial rulings than summary rulings, why not just make up your mind beforehand, but let the trial go through, and then rule afterward, and then it's easier to uphold? It's horrible for everybody else, but you aren't paying the legal fees.

(Not that I think judges should do this, just wondering about the incentives.)

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by grellas on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:41AM (#1457388)
A bit of legal theory here.

When a case is filed, a party brings a complaint, which sets forth allegations constituting claims for relief. The allegations are factual in nature but are generally stated.

A party who has been sued ultimately responds to the complaint by filing an answer in which he admits or denies the allegations made against him. In the normal case, most material allegations are denied.

The allegations that have been denied form the factual issues in the case, which ultimately must be decided by a trier of fact at a trial. When the facts have been so determined at a trial, the law is applied to them to determine whether one or more claims has been proved as to all of their elements (liability and damages or other relief sought) and, if so, judgment is entered on such claims against the wrongdoing party.

The time between the filing of a complaint and the date of a trial is typically a year or more.

Between the original filing and the trial, discovery is conducted by the parties. Discovery is done through a range of legal mechanisms that allow each party to discover what evidence underlies another party's case. This can be through written interrogatories, document requests, admission requests, depositions, etc. The idea behind discovery is to find out what admissible evidence exists to support the allegations that are at issue in the case.

After a reasonable period has passed for each party to conduct discovery, any party can move for summary judgment if it wishes. This is a tough motion to win. In essence, a party asking for summary judgment is telling the judge that, based on all the undisputed evidence that will be before the court in connection with the motion (evidence submitted by the moving party and by the opposing party), the moving party will be entitled to judgment "as a matter of law." If the court agrees that there are no material undisputed facts relating to all the essential pieces of a claim in the case, or if the undisputed facts show that there is an insuperable barrier to relief on a party's ability to prove a claim, the court can make a legal determination that such a claim be disposed of then and there and without need of allowing that claim to reach trial.

At a trial, it is normally up the "trier of fact" to resolve all factual disputes framed by the justiciable issues in the case. That usually means a jury (assuming one or more parties has demanded a jury trial). And, since the right to a jury is constitutionally guaranteed, a judge has no authority to supplant the authority of a jury to determine factual disputes at the trial. If no one has demanded a jury, or if the nature of a claim is such that is not triable to a jury, then the judge acts as the trier of fact in lieu of a jury. In either case, when a case presents disputed material facts that need to be resolved before it can be decided, the resolution of such facts is always left for trial and cannot be short-circuited by a judge before trial.

Thus, when (as in this case) a judge is presented with a summary judgment motion, the judge cannot dispose of any claims without first finding that the material facts relating to the claim being ruled upon are undisputed. If, in the course of the motion, a party presents evidence that, if believed at trial, would support that person's position and potentially support a judgment in that person's favor, then the judge must hold that disputed facts exist that preclude the claim's being dismissed summarily before trial.

That is why summary judgment is so hard to get. In virtually every case that is fought in court, a party will have something to present in terms of evidence that might allow that party to win at a trial. The evidence may not be strong or particularly credible, but a court has no power to weigh the strength of evidence in deciding whether to enter summary judgment. If contradictory evidence is presented, and is material to an issue, then summary judgment is automatically denied.

In this case, Viacom basically admitted that, with respect to every take down notice involved in the case, Google had acted promptly to remove the offending material. The judge also acknowledged that Viacom had presented evidence that (if believed) suggested that Google knew that there was widespread copyright infringement on its YouTube site and that it even encouraged such infringing activities so as to profit from them. Having so assessed the evidence, the judge interpreted the DMCA in a way that this latter evidence was irrelevant to any issue in the case - that is, it was not material to the resolution of the infringement claims that Google might have wanted to profit from infringing activity because all that mattered under DMCA is that Google always acted quickly to do the take downs whenever Viacom flagged an offending item. Having so construed the law, and given that Viacom had no evidence to dispute the fact that Google at all times acted promptly to do the take-downs, the judge held as a matter of law that there was nothing left for a jury to decide at a trial and that the judge could therefore enter a judgment on such issues summarily before trial for Google and against Viacom.

In this context, a judge would not have any particular incentive normally to avoid entering summary judgment just to try to make any ultimate ruling more appeal-proof. If the judge here, for example, had denied the motion and let the case go to trial, this would simply have put a jury through a useless exercise of trying to determine certain facts that the judge did not regard as relevant anyway. In the end, thinking as he did, this judge would have wound up with the same result in any case.

When considering incentives generally, though, it is true that is generally "safe" for a judge to deny summary judgment in most cases, even when a party has otherwise made a pretty compelling case, because that decision is not appealable and the net effect of the denial is to force the parties to go to trial. In such a case, in order to protect his record and avoid the potential for reversal on appeal, a judge essentially "kicks the can down the road" and fails to do the right thing that would save all parties a great deal of time, effort, and expense. This does unfortunately happen and is a source of great frustration to litigants in some cases. It also means that meritless cases can get to a full jury trial, where the pressure to settle is great just because a party would rather pay at that point rather than take unnecessary risks with what a jury might do.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by ramchip on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:23AM (#1457441)
The allegations are factual in nature but are generally stated

Minor thing, but could you clarify this statement? Do you mean "usually stated", or "stated in a general manner"? I'm unsure about the legal meaning of the words.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by pmccool on Thursday June 24, 2010 @05:08AM (#1457657)
Stated in a general manner. What's being alleged rather than the evidence to support it.
Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by dhimes on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:28AM (#1457986)
grellas,

Thank you for taking the time to post this explanation and make it so clear. I know that takes quite a bit of effort, and I for one appreciate it.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by alex_c on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:03AM (#1457347)
Just thinking out loud here - a judge might not want to burden the innocent party with a lengthy and expensive trial.
Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by babblefrog on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:39PM (#1456822)
Wasn't this the very purpose of the DMCA safe-harbor provision? This seems like a slam-dunk for Google.
Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by grellas on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:47PM (#1456843)
Yes, I think it is and it appears therefore that the judge was correct in his interpretation of the statute as worded.

Viacom and other rights holders will likely play out the policy debate before Congress, arguing that DMCA should be amended to impose broader obligations on hosting parties (such as the obligation to remove whole categories of materials on request). Of course, Viacom will also argue on appeal that the DMCA already imposes such broader obligations (as they unsuccessfully argued to the trial judge here).

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by roc on Thursday June 24, 2010 @12:12PM (#1458353)
Removing categories of materials on request assumes categories exist.

How would those categories be created if Google can't pro-actively scan content without running afoul of Safe Harbor's requirement that providers not vet material beforehand?

Am I misunderstanding something? Because it sounds like arguing for a "Category Take Down" is just a round-about way of arguing against Safe Harbor altogether.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by haihai on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:27AM (#1457373)
Loooking at a site like Justin.tv, and this judgment, even with the kind of blatant infringement visible here: http://www.justin.tv/directory/all

Would you, as their lawyer, feel quite safe that they would win any potentials lawsuits against them?

And given the obviousness of the infringement does the fact that there are money-making ads on the infringing content make it so they're knowingly profiting from infringement, thus invalidating the DMCAs safe harbor?

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by illumin8 on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:52AM (#1458028)
To be honest, it doesn't matter what they are hosting. The important thing from a legal point of view, is how they respond to DMCA takedown notices. If you have 100 infringing pieces of material on your site and you only get 1 takedown notice, you only have to remove the 1 piece of infringing material.

The law is pretty clear. It's not the webhost or ISPs obligation to police it's own content. That would put the ISP or webhost in the position of having to determine who the copyright owner of every piece of material on their site was. It is the copyright owner's obligation to send a proper DMCA takedown notice when infringing material is found.

Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by haihai on Thursday June 24, 2010 @11:13AM (#1458199)
Are you a lawyer that's familiar with DMCA issues?
Re:YouTube wins case against Viacom by physcab on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @08:14PM (#1456897)
I'm curious to know, what do you think will happen to the safe harbor provision of the DMCA? Do you think they are at risk for being amended to more conservative terms? Or is there a growing tide within the legal community to preserve its current state due to the proliferation of online media?

It seems (recently) the line has been drawn on what is considered "direct financial benefit", with the verdicts going against LimeWire and for Google.