Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by petercooper on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @05:27PM
(#1456417)
The world might not be, but the United Kingdom seems to be. I've seen a few of these over the last year. I must admit, it didn't stand out as anything particularly revolutionary or interesting at the time, but I guess it must be.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by sqrt17 on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @05:32PM
(#1456441)
Agreed. Where I went to college (Germany), they also had waterless urinals. The biggest problem seemed to be that people would throw cigarettes and stuff into them.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by jufemaiz on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @06:05PM
(#1456569)
One of the biggest problems for sewerage systems in general is people putting things down there that aren't meant to be there.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by roel_v on Thursday June 24, 2010 @04:26AM
(#1457602)
Well yeah, but how do you communicate what is meant to be there and what not? Diapers, well it's obvious that that shouldn't be there. But ground up biological waste actually improves the functioning of water treatment stations (depending on the technology used). So now is a tea bag OK to grind up and flush? What if it's one of those newfangled plastic tea bags? Those are not OK but it's not obvious that they aren't (I wouldn't have known if one hadn't got stuck in my grinder...).
An interesting problem - improving on a system that is so behind the scenes that hardly anyone ever thinks about its functioning. To make changes to that, you need large scale social engineering techniques to implement those changes - a 'message of general interest' or two on TV isn't going to cut it.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by pmjordan on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @05:43PM
(#1456485)
They have waterless urinals at most of the motorway service stations in Germany. They seem to work well, but then they're kept spotless, probably to justify charging 50 cents to use them.
Ikea (in Austria at least) use them too; they're not kept as spotless, and I've seen them out of order occasionally.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal?
by tomjen3 on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @09:39PM
(#1457055)
In general nearly all the public toilets in Germany are kept spotless, whether they are urinals or not, and you generally have to pay 50 cents to use them (or 20 cents, if you are not on the autobahn).
Compared to the alternative of gross toilets it is a win-win situation.