News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by Dolores12 on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:09PM (#14561667)
when telegram has been proven insecure? in every topic about telegram people keep saying telegram is not secure. i failed to find info about how insecure their secure chats. maybe you can help me?
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by bascule on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:45PM (#14562020)
Their homebrew crypto seems very shaky:

https://cs.au.dk/~jakjak/master-thesis.pdf

https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/1177.pdf

tl;dr: they tried to use SHA-1 as a MAC. This is something of a crypto 101 mistake. Had they even used HMAC they'd be in much better shape. Worse, even after this was pointed out to them and people started writing papers about potential attacks, they have stood by their shaky design, refusing to update it or even admit mistakes were made in the initial design.

But even worse than that, end-to-end encryption is off-by-default, and users must opt into it. Why?

https://telegram.org/faq#q-why-not-just-make-all-chats-secre...

"This allows Telegram to be widely adopted in broad circles, not just by activists and dissidents, so that the simple fact of using Telegram does not mark users as targets for heightened surveillance in certain countries. We are convinced that the separation of conversations into Cloud and Secret chats represents the most secure solution currently possible for a massively popular messaging application."

Putting aside the fact that if Telegram's cryptography were properly implemented, an outside observer shouldn't be able to tell whether or not end-to-end encryption is being used or not (i.e. Telegram does not provide proper separation of data-at-rest versus data-in-motion), this seems to be the "I don't need encryption because I have nothing to hide" argument, but perpetrated by what's allegedly supposed to be a secure messenger.

The real reason why Telegram doesn't enable end-to-end encryption is pretty clear: they don't have the features to provide a good end-to-end encryption experience: They don't support end-to-end encrypted group chats. They don't have encrypted backups like Signal and WhatsApp.

Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by ycmbntrthrwaway on Thursday June 15, 2017 @05:11PM (#14564402)
> But even worse than that, end-to-end encryption is off-by-default, and users must opt into it. Why?

Because it is unusable. It has no synchronization between devices, only 1 device to 1 device. And if you accidentally closed the chat, you have to verify it again. You can't store trusted key fingerprint.

It is not suitable for mobile devices. Secure chats are like OTR, but with bad crypto. Signal and WhatsApp are the same protocol as OMEMO, originally designed for Signal.

> so that the simple fact of using Telegram does not mark users as targets for heightened surveillance in certain countries

And yet Telegram is associated with terrorism more that, e.g., WhatsApp.

Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by notheguyouthink on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:42PM (#14561988)
I think he's spreading a lie.. based on what I've seen, at least.

It's a not yet proven secure protocol, is the worst you can say against it I believe. I'm not a security guy mind you, I'm just parroting what I keep seeing. Rightfully so, lack of deep audit is a very valid reason to worry. Yet, worry and untrusted is vastly different than actively exploitable / broken.

Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by roywiggins on Thursday June 15, 2017 @03:59PM (#14563877)
Encryption should probably be considered broken until demonstrated otherwise.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by memmcgee on Thursday June 15, 2017 @08:23PM (#14565613)
By that logic all encryption is broken.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by narrowrail on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:39PM (#14561960)
Many prominent and respected HNers have laid out the case for why Telegram has security issues. If you use the search function at the bottom, you will easily find these issues raised. I don't personally possess the knowledge to determine the soundness of Telegram's crypto, but there have been enough red flags raised on HN over the years to merit skepticism.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by RodericDay on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:54PM (#14562102)
tbh, people like tptacek and his buddies have a clear agenda and attitude of their own. I'm definitely not sated by their pronouncements alone.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by daxorid on Thursday June 15, 2017 @01:37PM (#14562491)
While I absolutely agree with you about the "tptacek & friends" agenda, that really has no bearing whatsoever on the actual problems they've raised with MTProto, their weird KDF, and IGE in general.

Whenever one can consider a person's arguments in isolation from your opinion of said person, it's wise to do so. This is one of those opportunities.

Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by tanderson92 on Thursday June 15, 2017 @08:49PM (#14565750)
Can you elaborate on what that agenda is?
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by Dolores12 on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:44PM (#14562016)
Is that how you prove something - by reading comments on HN? Oh, how about all these red flags are raised to scare people to not let them use Telegram which is really secure?
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by WillyOnWheels on Thursday June 15, 2017 @05:34PM (#14564570)
> Is that how you prove something - by reading comments on HN?

I enjoy the comments of tpacek and ryanlol

Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by Dolores12 on Friday June 16, 2017 @02:53AM (#14567101)
I don't think you answered my question.
Re:Telegram founder: US intelligence tried to bribe us to we... by WillyOnWheels on Friday June 16, 2017 @05:29PM (#14572783)
I don't base my life on them but I think tpacek and ryanlol know more about computer security than I do.