News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by TrevorBurnham on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @03:39PM (#1456035)
Normally I wouldn't post something about urinals to HN just because it's in Wired, but this is actually a fascinating article about a new technology's introduction being delayed by resistance from trade unions (in this case, plumbers).
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by EliAndrewC on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:41AM (#1458004)
I'd say that this is especially relevant to hackers in corporate environments because of this passage:

"Hansen heard a flood of complaints early on: The urinals stank. They were dirty. Where was the flush handle? In one building, the complaints were so vociferous that Hansen started an investigation. He found that the bathrooms did indeed stink, but the urinals appeared clean ....

... The urinals, however, emitted nothing. The cartridges were doing their job. Hansen moved the sewer vent and replaced the cracked toilet. The complaints stopped. Hansen concluded that the smell had always been there, but people didn’t have anything to blame it on until the new urinals arrived."

I've experienced this many times. I create/modify/install PROGRAM_X and immediately receive complaints that it's causing problems on the server where it's running. Investigation eventually reveals that these problems have been going on for some time, but now there's something to blame. I'm sure I'm not alone.

Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by _delirium on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @04:59PM (#1456311)
Although I thought the insistence on running pipes was a waste, it turned out at my university to be a good thing they installed the pipes (capped off initially) even though they were installing waterfree urinals, because after they kept clogging up and cost way more in maintenance costs than they were saving in water, they switched back to low-flush urinals. If they hadn't run the capped-off pipes initially, they would've been stuck.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by warfangle on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @05:17PM (#1456382)
It seems as though if they're properly (and regularly) maintained, they don't clog. Sounds like your university's periodic (compared to acute - think janitor) maintenance workers were improperly trained on how to care for them. The second page of the article explains this.

(edit: on second thought, it was a university. Knowing what university students tend to put in urinals, I'm not surprised they clogged even with proper maintenance)

Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by misterbwong on Thursday June 24, 2010 @12:15PM (#1458365)
They should design a "self cleaning" model that actually uses the piping behind the urinal to flush once a week or so. It seems like this would resolve the need to rely on human maintenance, although the urinal wouldn't truly be waterless anymore.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by _delirium on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @05:50PM (#1456517)
I agree it's probably possible to maintain them well, but it seems it's still a cost. If nothing else, you have to pay for better maintenance workers, or more oversight of them.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by brianpan on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:00PM (#1456720)
I've seen these toilets in action and from my few encounters, they work as advertised.

But after reading about how they work, I have reservations on the design. Depending on maintenance for keeping sewer gases from escaping seems failure prone. Humans err (and get lazy). I'd much rather depend on plumbing codes that have been tested over decades and work "automatically" than depending on changing a cartridge.

What happens if a bathroom with a waterless toilet is abandoned or isn't maintained regularly?

Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by inferno0069 on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:23PM (#1456782)
The traditional U-trap can fail if abandoned or isn't used regularly too. The water eventually evaporates.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by eru on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @09:04PM (#1456987)
Happened to me regularly when returning from summer holidays.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by ars on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @09:17PM (#1457014)
To prevent it, put a small amount of mineral oil (baby oil) in the trap.

It will float on top and prevent the water from evaporating.

Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by eru on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @09:33PM (#1457044)
I guess vegetable oil should also work? By the way, I heard of the same trick for keeping water in your vases.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by ars on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @11:30PM (#1457232)
Vegetable oil will oxidize and turn into a sticky mess.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by eru on Thursday June 24, 2010 @10:46AM (#1458142)
OK, thanks.
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by dtf on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:58PM (#1456869)
It's not just the trade unions. Here's a quote from a similar story in the Washington Post:

"Users complain that high-efficiency toilets, which use less water than traditional models, require two flushes to do the job. Behind such objections stands this truth: America remains a flush-oriented society, and the more powerful the flush, the better. "It was a morale issue," Anja S. Caldwell, green building chief for the Montgomery County public school system, said of initial resistance to the 50 waterless urinals introduced over the past year. "People thought that by taking the flush away, you're taking an entitlement."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06...

Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by SoftwareMaven on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @08:48PM (#1456957)
If that's what people think, then by all means, get all flushing urinals out of our society.

I would readily give the gallon of water from my urinal to my "standard" toilet flush for when I need it.

   ___
  [   ]
   ---
   (@)
    -
Re:Is the world ready for the waterless urinal? by agentultra on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:17AM (#1457965)
Been happening with coal since the introduction of nuclear power.

The anti-nuclear/anti-weaponization movement didn't help either.

Great article. Just goes to show that there's still so much more to innovate out there.