Re:How Microsoft is changing the programming world
by chc on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @03:19PM
(#1455956)
Creation without understanding is shallow. You don't just learn the technique of playing piano and then crank out beautiful symphonies. You don't learn how to draw a blueprint and create world-class architecture. You don't memorize the times table and start doing advanced physics calculations. Knowledge of the history and state of the art is a huge component in creating great things.
And the statement that there's "little practice" in Lisp is a statement about the current mindset of most programmers, not about the language itself. Whether it's useful is orthogonal to whether people use it.
Re:How Microsoft is changing the programming world
by kenjackson on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @03:36PM
(#1456018)
Understanding necessary for creation is... well... necessary. But "amassing knowledge" is simply amassing knowledge. I can amass knowledge all day long, but if I don't understand or create it really is simply mental masturbation.
And my statement about Lisp was just about the state of the world. It's a fine language, but we shouldn't pretend that its used more than it is. Actually in teaching it is used a fair bit, and teaching is practice of a sort.
And to be honest, there was little practice in Lisp before 2000... and frankly little after 2000.