News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by dom0 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @05:41PM (#14556327)
Linux ~4.7 or so fixed a bug in fadvise, specifically FADV_DONTNEED, that incorrectly rounded page boundaries to the effect of making some calls less effective. Found and fixed by a developer who wondered why his page cache was filling up, even though the backup software he used made use of DONTNEED :)

The bug was in from day 1.

Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by carussell on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @06:09PM (#14556511)
The thing I wonder about in instances like this is how many people ran into the problem and thought, "Huh, there must be some quirky rationale here, and it's just an idiosyncrasy I'll have to deal with", or, "Huh, that's definitely wrong... oh well".
Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by aisofteng on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @08:07PM (#14556986)
I can definitely say that I've been guilty of seeing a subtle but not deal breaking bug in third party open source software and then failing to file a report because there's just so much to do in a day that it's easy to forget. It's on all of us to be good open source citizens.
Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by ethbro on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:30PM (#14557522)
I think the counter point of this is being kind when people report bugs that aren't bugs.

If users encounter a weird result, report it, and have someone call them an idiot because they misunderstood a nuance of the system... they're​ probably not going to take the time to report next time around.

(And I get it, there's that common issue that people consistently misunderstand and you continually get reports about. But each one of those users might also be a user who finds a real bug next time.)

Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by lomnakkus on Thursday June 15, 2017 @03:51AM (#14558620)
I think your parenthetical probably explains the dismissive attitude many upstreams have, but I would argue that if so many people are (consistently) misunderstanding your software then there's probably a UI/UX/education problem that needs fixin'...

(Not saying it's easy, but it's a sign...)

Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by alkonaut on Thursday June 15, 2017 @09:39AM (#14560218)
Someone said, somewhere: User files bug that isn't a bug:

bad/rookie dev: omg dumb user

good dev: closes bug issue, files new issue to fix docs.

Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by 13of40 on Thursday June 15, 2017 @10:00AM (#14560410)
Years back, I spent some time doing QA for an operating system, and I noticed that there was a strong tendency in people to deny the possibility that the operating system had a bug when they noticed something wrong and instead put all their energy into fixing test automation, finding workarounds, etc. And a lot of these were people whose sole purpose at work was finding and reporting bugs in the OS.
Re:How I Found a 20-Year-Old Linux Kernel Bug by dom0 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @06:56PM (#14556700)
Ah, I almost got it right. It discarded too much, thus reducing throughput - even more subtle.

https://github.com/torvalds/linux/commit/18aba41cbfbcd138e9f...